The Lies That Separated Us and the Truth That Brought Us Home

Chapter 32

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Catherine looked at Eleanor for a long moment. “Daniel?”

“Yes.”

“He said he would come back.”

Eleanor lowered her eyes. “He can't. I'm sorry.”

Catherine stepped aside. The sitting room was neat and warm, with a sewing basket on the table and a row of family photographs along the mantel. One photograph showed a young woman holding a newborn baby wrapped in a hospital blanket.

Catherine saw Eleanor looking at it.

“That was my son,” she said. “Or the child I was told was my son. I never got to hold him properly. They said he died before I woke up.”

“Daniel found evidence that he was taken.”

Catherine's hand trembled. “I know. A woman came to see me after he died. She said she had been looking for me. She showed me a photograph of a boy at St. Agnes. She said he might be mine.”

“Who was the woman?”

“Amelia.”

Amelia stepped forward. “I found your file in the Glasshouse. I'm sorry I didn't come sooner.”

Catherine studied her face. “You were the little girl with the bracelet.”

Amelia nodded.

Catherine began to cry. “Then they moved all of you.”

“Not all,” Eleanor said. “We are still trying to understand what happened.”

Catherine took a photograph from a drawer. It showed three babies in a hospital nursery. Two lay side by side. The third was in a separate cot, wearing a white knitted cap.

Eleanor recognised the crescent mark beneath the ear of the baby in the nearer cot. The third baby's face was turned toward the camera.

“That's the boy,” Catherine said. “That's my son.”

Oliver stared at the photograph. “He looks like me.”

Catherine looked at him, and something in her expression shifted. “No. He looks like his father.”

She turned the photograph over. On the back, in faded blue ink, was a name.

**Matthew Whitmore.**

Oliver's breath caught.

Catherine touched the photograph with one finger. “Matthew came to see me before the baby was born. He said he loved me. He said his family would never accept us. Then he disappeared. I was told he had died in an accident.”

“Did you see him again?” Eleanor asked.

Catherine shook her head. “No. But a few weeks after the birth, I received a letter. It said he was alive and that he wanted the baby to be safe. It was signed with his initials.”

Peter asked where the letter was.

“I gave it to Daniel. He said it might help prove the truth.”

“Do you have a copy?”

Catherine nodded. She went to the bedroom and returned with a small tin. Inside was a folded letter, its paper yellowed and brittle.

The message was brief.

*Catherine, I am alive. I cannot come for you yet. They are watching every road and every telephone. Keep the boy safe. If anyone asks, he was never born. I will find you when I can. M.*

Eleanor read the note aloud. The signature was unmistakable.

“Matthew survived the boating accident,” Sophie said.

“Or someone wrote this to make Catherine believe he had,” Reed replied.

Catherine shook her head. “I saw him after the accident. He came to the house one night. He was thinner, with a scar on his cheek. He said he had to leave before morning. He told me to trust Daniel.”

“Where did he go?” Eleanor asked.

“He said he was going north. To a place where no one would think to look.”

Peter closed his eyes. “The island.”

“What island?” Reed asked.

“Greyhaven. The Whitmore family owned a cottage there. Matthew used to go when he wanted to be alone.”

Reed immediately called the regional unit and requested a search of property records. The cottage had been sold under a false name seven years earlier, but the electricity account had been active until the previous winter.

“Someone was living there,” he said.

Catherine gripped the edge of the table. “If Matthew is alive, he may know what happened to my son.”

Oliver looked at her. “And if I'm that son?”

She studied him, searching his face for a resemblance that years of uncertainty had taught her not to trust.

“Then I have found you twice,” she said. “Once in a photograph, and once in person.”

Reed arranged for Catherine to be moved to a secure address. Before they left, she handed Oliver the tin with the letter and the photograph.

“You should keep these,” she said. “They belong to you.”

Oliver accepted them with both hands.

As they drove away, Eleanor looked at the photograph again. The three babies had been placed in the same room, but their lives had been divided by signatures and lies. She wondered how many people had known. How many had looked at the children and decided that the truth was less important than the arrangement.

News in the same category

The Lies That Separated Us and the Truth That Brought Us Home

45 Part