THE OLD MAN THEY LAUGHED AT

Chapter 13

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"No."

"Did you discuss similar practices with him?"

Victor paused.

"We have discussed the need to allocate staff time efficiently. That's a normal part of retail management."

"Did you instruct managers to prioritize customers based on their appearance?"

"Not in those words."

"What words did you use?"

Victor leaned back.

"Thomas, I think we should be careful not to turn an ordinary discussion about sales efficiency into a question of ethics."

Thomas remained expressionless.

"Then answer the question."

Victor's smile faded slightly.

"I told managers to identify customers who were likely to make a purchase and to ensure that our best sales associates were available to serve them."

"And how were they supposed to identify those customers?"

"Through experience. Body language. Questions. The products they asked about. Sometimes the way they presented themselves."

"Their clothing?"

"Among other things."

"Their watches?"

"If someone is wearing a high-end watch, that may suggest an interest in luxury products."

"And if someone isn't?"

"It tells you less."

Thomas nodded.

"So you acknowledge that appearance was being used as a factor."

"Of course. Sales is about understanding people. We make judgments all the time."

Thomas opened another folder.

"Did you tell Natalie Brooks to remove customer-retention data from an executive presentation?"

Victor looked toward Robert before answering.

"I remember reviewing a draft. The data needed further validation."

"Did you tell her to remove it?"

"I told her not to present figures that hadn't been fully contextualized."

"That wasn't my question."

Victor's expression hardened.

"Yes. I asked her to remove the comparison until the analysis was complete."

"Was the analysis incomplete?"

"At the time, I believed it was."

"Did you later ask for the analysis to be completed?"

Victor hesitated.

"I don't recall."

Thomas placed Natalie's email exchange on the table.

"She provided the underlying figures. You acknowledged receiving them. You then closed the ethics complaint she submitted about the same practices."

Victor's posture changed.

"That complaint was not an ethics matter. It was a disagreement about management methodology."

"You decided that yourself?"

"I was responsible for the regional operations involved."

"Which is why you should not have been the person deciding whether the complaint against your own practices was resolved."

Victor looked at Helen Price.

"Was there a procedural violation?"

Helen answered carefully.

"Based on the record currently available, the complaint should have been reviewed independently. That did not happen."

Victor shook his head.

"This is becoming absurd. We're talking about a few emails, some customer complaints, and an employee who disagreed with her supervisor."

Thomas folded his hands.

"No. We're talking about whether this company has encouraged employees to judge customers by appearance, whether management ignored evidence of declining customer retention, and whether a formal complaint was closed by the person whose conduct it questioned."

Victor looked directly at him.

"And we're talking about a company that needs to remain profitable."

"Yes."

"Then you understand the realities of the business."

"I do."

Thomas leaned forward.

"I understand that our employees cannot spend an unlimited amount of time with every visitor. I understand that some customers need more assistance than others. I understand that our premium collections are important to our profitability."

He paused.

"What I do not accept is the idea that a person must look wealthy before we treat them with courtesy."

Victor sighed.

"No one has suggested that we should be discourteous."

"Adrian Cole did."

"Adrian made a mistake."

"Adrian's mistake was consistent with the behavior our investigation is uncovering."

"Then discipline Adrian. Don't rewrite the company's entire sales strategy because one employee was rude."

Thomas looked at him for a long moment.

"Do you know why I returned to the Fifth Avenue boutique this week?"

Victor seemed surprised by the question.

"No."

"I wanted to see a watch that reminded me of my wife."

Thomas described the encounter with Adrian, including the remark about his clothing and the salesman's refusal to show him the watch.

Victor listened, his expression becoming increasingly uncomfortable.

When Thomas finished, Victor shook his head.

"That's unfortunate. But surely you can see how unusual the circumstances were. Adrian didn't recognize you."

Thomas's voice became very quiet.

"Neither did I ask him to."

Victor stopped speaking.

Thomas continued.

"Would Adrian's behavior have been acceptable if I were a retired mechanic? A schoolteacher? A delivery driver who had spent thirty years saving to buy a watch for his wife?"

"No."

"Then why does the fact that he didn't recognize me matter?"

"It doesn't excuse what he said."

"Good. Then we agree."

Victor glanced toward Robert.

The chief operating officer had remained silent throughout most of the conversation.

Victor seemed to be seeking reassurance that the discussion could still be redirected toward commercial performance.

Robert finally spoke.

"Thomas, I think we should consider the wider implications before making sweeping changes. Victor's team has delivered substantial improvements in revenue."

Thomas turned toward him.

"I am considering the wider implications. That is why we are here."

Robert opened his mouth, but Thomas continued.

"We cannot claim that our sales strategy is successful while ignoring the customers who have stopped returning. We cannot congratulate ourselves for higher transaction values without examining how those results were achieved."

Victor tapped the folder with one finger.

"With respect, the numbers are not as simple as Natalie has presented them. The market has changed. Customers are buying differently. Online sales have increased, and younger buyers are entering the market through different channels."

"Those are legitimate factors," Thomas replied. "Which is why we need a complete analysis rather than a selective one."

Victor's expression tightened.

"What exactly do you intend to do?"

"Effective immediately, we will suspend the proposed appearance-based customer-prioritization targets. The customer-retention figures will be restored to the executive reporting package. The handling of Natalie's complaint will be independently reviewed."

Victor stared at him.

"And my role?"

"You will continue your normal responsibilities while the review is underway. You will also provide the relevant communications, meeting records, and performance guidelines requested by the investigators."

Victor's jaw tightened.

News in the same category

THE OLD MAN THEY LAUGHED AT

20 Part