"Not in the beginning. I thought the problem would correct itself. I was wrong."
Samuel's answer was so direct that Thomas felt an unexpected wave of sadness.
"What changed your mind?"
"A customer."
Thomas waited.
"An elderly woman brought in a watch that had belonged to her husband. It was a modest piece, and the repair would have cost more than the watch was worth on the secondhand market. She wanted to know whether it could be restored because her husband had worn it for forty years."
Thomas remembered Evelyn Carter immediately.
"What happened?"
"The sales associate told her it wasn't worth repairing. He suggested that she purchase something new. She left without an estimate."
Samuel paused.
"I learned about it later because she brought the watch to our workshop through another employee. When I examined it, I found that the movement was in remarkably good condition. It needed servicing, not replacement."
"What did you do?"
"I explained the options to her. She chose to repair it."
Samuel's voice softened.
"When she collected it, she held the watch against her ear and smiled. She said she hadn't heard it ticking since her husband died."
Thomas looked down at his hands.
"Was that the same woman who visited the Fifth Avenue boutique last week?"
"I don't know. There have been several similar cases."
Several.
The word settled heavily in Thomas's mind.
"Samuel, why didn't you tell me about this earlier?"
"I tried to tell Daniel's predecessor. I spoke to two regional managers. I wrote a memo to the workshop director."
"And what happened?"
"The memo was returned with a note saying that repair consultations should focus on commercially viable opportunities."
Thomas's expression hardened.
"Do you still have the memo?"
"I kept a copy."
"Bring it tomorrow."
"I will."
After the call ended, Thomas remained seated for several minutes.
He remembered the early days of Vacheron House, when Samuel had joined the company as a young technician with a small toolbox and a remarkable ability to repair delicate movements.
Samuel had never been interested in selling watches.
He cared about how they worked.
He believed that every object deserved an honest examination before someone declared it worthless.
Thomas had once described him as the conscience of the workshop.
Now he wondered whether the company had spent years ignoring that conscience because it was inconvenient.
The following morning, Samuel arrived at headquarters carrying a worn leather briefcase.
He looked older than Thomas remembered, but his handshake was still firm.
"Good to see you, old friend," Samuel said.
"You too."
Thomas led him into a private meeting room.
Coffee was waiting on the table, along with copies of the customer-service reports.
Samuel placed his briefcase beside his chair and opened it.
From inside, he removed a folder containing several handwritten notes, printed emails, and a memo dated three years earlier.
Thomas read the first page.
The memo described a growing tendency among some sales associates to dismiss repair inquiries from customers who appeared unlikely to purchase new products.
It recommended that the company establish a standard procedure for evaluating sentimental and vintage timepieces, ensuring that customers received accurate information before being encouraged to replace their watches.
At the bottom was Samuel's signature.
Beside it was a handwritten note from a former workshop director.
Not aligned with current commercial priorities. Please focus on service efficiency.
Thomas read the note twice.
"Who wrote this?"
"Martin Ellison. He was workshop director at the time."
"Where is he now?"
"He left the company two years ago."
"Did he explain why?"
Samuel nodded.
"He told me he wanted to work somewhere that treated craftsmanship as more than a marketing phrase."
Thomas looked up.
"Did you speak to him after he left?"
"Once. He said that the company had become so focused on selling new watches that it had started treating repairs as an obstacle rather than a service."
Thomas leaned back.
"That's difficult to hear."
"It's more difficult to watch happen."
Samuel opened another section of the folder.
"This is a list of repair inquiries that were marked as abandoned or commercially unsuitable. I don't know whether all of them were handled badly, but several customers told us they had been discouraged from pursuing repairs."
Thomas examined the names and dates.
One entry described a retired teacher who wanted to restore a watch inherited from her father.
Another concerned a construction worker who had saved a small amount each month to purchase a mechanical watch for his son's graduation.
A third involved a woman who wanted to replace the broken strap on a modest timepiece she had worn throughout her nursing career.
The notes were brief, but Thomas could imagine each conversation.
A customer asking for help.
An employee deciding that the potential sale was too small.
A polite refusal disguised as practical advice.
The customer leaving with the impression that the business had nothing to offer them.
"How many cases are on this list?" Thomas asked.
"Forty-eight."
Thomas looked at him.
"Forty-eight?"
"Those are the cases I could verify from my own records. There may have been many more."
Thomas set the pages down carefully.
"Samuel, I need you to understand something. I won't assume that every case represents misconduct. We need to examine the circumstances, the repair costs, and the advice given to each customer."
"Of course."
"But if the records show that customers were discouraged from receiving honest assessments because their purchases were considered too small, we will have to address that."
Samuel nodded.
"That's all I ever wanted."
Thomas studied the old watchmaker.
"Why did you keep these records after retiring?"
Samuel smiled faintly.
"Because I knew someone would eventually ask the right question."
For a moment, Thomas could not answer.
Then he reached across the table and placed a hand on Samuel's shoulder.
"I'm sorry we didn't ask sooner."
Samuel looked at him.
"Don't apologize for not knowing everything. Apologize if you learn the truth and do nothing."
Thomas nodded slowly.
It was a fair distinction.
And it was one he intended to remember.
That afternoon, Thomas asked Samuel to help design a new service policy for the company's boutiques.
The policy would require staff to provide clear repair estimates, explain alternatives honestly, and distinguish sentimental value from resale value. Customers would never be pressured to purchase a replacement before receiving an assessment of their existing watch.
Samuel agreed, but he insisted on one condition.
"I don't want this to become another document that sits in a drawer."
Thomas smiled.
"Neither do I."
"Then the people working in the stores need to understand it. The sales associates, the managers, the technicians, everyone. And someone needs to check whether the policy is being followed."