THE OLD MAN THEY LAUGHED AT

Chapter 19

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Then he spoke.

"You're right about one thing, Victor. My experience has made the issue personal."

Victor appeared satisfied.

Thomas continued.

"But the reason I called this meeting is not that someone insulted me. It is that I discovered the same kind of behavior had affected other customers, that employees had raised concerns, and that those concerns had not received an appropriate review."

He placed Evelyn Carter's letter on the table.

"I have spoken with a retired nurse whose father's watch was dismissed as worthless because it was not commercially attractive. I have reviewed records from a master watchmaker who documented similar cases years ago. And I have heard from an analyst who tried to report declining customer retention but was told to remove the figures from an executive presentation."

Thomas looked around the room.

"These are not simply emotional reactions. They are operational failures."

Victor said nothing.

Thomas turned to the legal director.

"What is our obligation when a customer requests an honest assessment of a product or repair?"

The director answered carefully.

"We must provide accurate information, avoid misleading claims, and comply with applicable consumer-protection requirements. Our internal standards also require employees to communicate respectfully and transparently."

"And do our policies permit employees to refuse ordinary service because a customer appears unlikely to make a high-value purchase?"

"No."

"Do they permit a manager to close an ethics complaint involving their own conduct without independent review?"

"No."

Thomas nodded.

"Then we are not debating whether these practices are consistent with our standards. We are determining how they developed, who was responsible, and how to prevent them from continuing."

He looked toward the chief operating officer.

"Robert, I want your assessment of the proposed changes."

Robert cleared his throat.

"I support the general direction. My concern is implementation. We have nine boutiques, several hundred employees, and a sales organization that operates across different markets. Changes to compensation and performance measurement need to be carefully designed."

"Agreed."

"We should also ensure that managers aren't punished for making legitimate decisions about staffing and time allocation."

"Agreed again."

Robert appeared surprised by the response.

Thomas continued.

"The revised policy will not require employees to spend unlimited time with every visitor. It will require them to provide appropriate service without making assumptions about a customer's worth. Managers will retain discretion over staffing, but they will be accountable for how that discretion is exercised."

Robert nodded slowly.

"That seems workable."

Victor looked toward him.

"Robert, you understand that this could create significant uncertainty for regional managers."

"I do."

"Some of them have been operating under the existing performance expectations for years."

"Then they will need clear guidance about the new expectations."

Victor placed his pen on the table.

"I think we're moving too quickly."

Thomas met his gaze.

"Then tell me what information you need before we proceed."

Victor hesitated.

"I would want a more comprehensive review of the customer-retention data, a financial forecast of the proposed incentive changes, and an assessment of the potential effect on premium sales."

"Those are reasonable requests."

Thomas made a note.

"We will commission the analysis. In the meantime, the existing policies remain in force. No employee is to be encouraged to prioritize customers based on appearance, and no complaint involving a manager's own conduct is to be closed without independent review."

Victor's expression hardened.

"And if the analysis shows that the new incentive system reduces revenue?"

"Then we will examine why."

"What if it reduces revenue substantially?"

"Then we will determine whether the decline is caused by the new system, market conditions, staffing issues, or other factors. We will make decisions based on evidence."

Victor leaned forward.

"You cannot guarantee that these changes won't damage the business."

"No," Thomas replied. "And you cannot guarantee that the current system isn't already damaging it."

The words landed heavily.

For the first time, Victor appeared genuinely unsettled.

Thomas continued.

"We have been looking at the revenue we generate from customers who purchase our most expensive watches. We have not given enough attention to the customers who return for repairs, recommend us to friends, or spend years building trust with our employees."

He gestured toward the screen.

"Those relationships may not produce the largest transaction today. But they can determine whether the business is still healthy ten years from now."

The chief financial officer examined the figures again.

"I would like to review the lifetime value of repeat customers," he said. "We may be underestimating the long-term contribution of repair services and lower-value purchases."

Thomas nodded.

"Please do."

The meeting continued for another hour.

The executives debated the details of the new framework, the timing of the employee survey, and the need for independent oversight. Some supported Thomas's proposals enthusiastically. Others remained cautious, concerned about the financial and organizational consequences.

By the end of the meeting, they had agreed to establish a temporary review committee.

The committee would examine the sales incentives, complaint-handling procedures, customer-retention data, and repair-service records.

It would report directly to Thomas and the board's audit committee rather than to the regional sales organization.

Natalie Brooks would provide the underlying analysis, but an independent compliance team would verify the findings.

Samuel Reed would advise on the repair-service policy.

Daniel would oversee the revised customer-service training.

The first report would be due in thirty days.

As the executives began gathering their papers, Victor remained seated.

Thomas noticed.

"Is there something else you would like to discuss?"

Victor waited until the other executives had left.

Then he closed the conference-room door.

"I think we need to speak privately."

Thomas gestured toward the chair opposite him.

"Go ahead."

Victor sat down.

"I've spent five years trying to make this company more competitive. When I joined, we were losing ground to retailers who had better systems, more sophisticated customer analytics, and more disciplined sales operations."

Thomas listened.

"I helped change that. We improved our margins, reduced inventory waste, and increased premium sales. I recruited talented managers and gave them tools to perform better."

"I know."

"Then I don't understand why you're treating me as though I've deliberately undermined the company."

Thomas looked at him carefully.

"I'm not making that judgment. The investigation is examining decisions made under your supervision."

"But you have already suspended the targets associated with those decisions."

"Because the targets are under review."

Victor leaned forward.

"That distinction may be clear to you. It won't be clear to the managers who depend on those targets to evaluate their employees."

"Then we will explain it."

Victor exhaled sharply.

"You are risking the momentum we have built."

Thomas was quiet for a moment.

Then he asked a question that Victor did not expect.

"Have you ever had a customer thank you for helping them find something they could not afford to replace?"

Victor frowned.

"I don't understand."

"Have you ever helped someone repair an old watch, even when you knew the sale would produce almost no revenue?"

Victor appeared puzzled.

"My responsibilities are different. I oversee regional performance."

News in the same category

THE OLD MAN THEY LAUGHED AT

20 Part