The challenge arrived on paper, which was how Dylan Pierce wanted it.
Eleanor learned about it from Sarah, who came down the concrete steps between the bleachers and lane twenty-four with her phone in her hand and her nurse's face on, the face she wore when a piece of news had to be delivered whole and without decoration.
There's a formal protest, Sarah said. "It's on the officials' board and it's already on two of the sports feeds. He filed it an hour ago."
Eleanor was sitting on the low bench behind her lane with her rifle case open across her knees, not doing anything to the rifle, simply looking at it the way a person looks at a letter they have already read. The morning was still cool enough that the shade under the canopy felt honest. Beyond the flags the desert was beginning its daily brightening, the targets far out in the shimmer, reduced by distance to pale ideas of themselves.
Read it to me, Eleanor said.
Sarah read, halting once, not from emotion but from disbelief at the phrasing. The protest, lodged by Dylan Pierce, competitor, lane three, requested a full review of the second-round scores recorded at lane twenty-four and a complete equipment inspection of the rifle used to achieve them, on the grounds that the consistency of the results, in the conditions prevailing, raised a reasonable question as to whether the equipment conformed to the regulations of the competition.
He means you cheated, Sarah said.
He means he cannot otherwise explain it, Eleanor said. "That is a different thing, though it lands in the same place."
You aren't angry.
I am deciding what to do with being angry. There is a difference, and at my age it matters where you spend it.
Mason Reed came down the firing line at his referee's pace, which was unhurried in a way that made other people hurry less. He carried a clipboard against his chest like a shield he had long ago stopped noticing he owned. He stopped at the painted line behind her lane and waited until she looked up, because he had learned in two days that Eleanor Brooks did not respond well to being addressed while her attention was elsewhere, not from rudeness but from economy.
Mrs. Brooks, he said. "You've heard."
Sarah has read it to me.
Then you know I have no discretion in it. A formal challenge, properly filed, requires a full inspection and a review of the scores. The rules are plain. I wanted you to hear the procedure from me before you hear it from anyone else.
Tell me the procedure, she said.
The competition pauses for your lane and his. The rifle is taken to the inspection tent by two officials, in your sight if you wish to be present, and I would advise that you are present. It is examined against every regulation that applies. The scores are reviewed against the electronic record and the target record together. Then the findings are announced, publicly, because the challenge was filed publicly. He paused. "That last part is not my choice either. The filing was made where cameras could see it."
It was meant to be seen, Eleanor said.
Yes, ma'am. I believe it was.
When?
Eleven o'clock. The range will hold the other lanes until the announcement.
Sarah made a small sound. "Eleven. That's two hours of every television person here inventing reasons."
They would invent them anyway, Eleanor said. "At least this way they will invent them about a procedure, and procedures end."
Mason looked down at the rifle in its open case. He had looked at it several times now, across two days, and each time it had been the same: an old rifle, clean, plainly kept, with nothing about it that performed for anyone. He had also, twice more since the first morning, seen the edge of the silver watch beneath her glove, and he had not asked about it, and he was aware that not asking had become its own kind of statement between them.
You may have a representative with you, he said. "A coach, if you have one. Family."
I have Sarah, Eleanor said. "And I have the rifle. Between them they know everything there is to know about the matter."
When he had gone, the firing line settled into the particular quiet of a place where an event has been announced but has not yet occurred. Competitors at the nearer lanes pretended to attend to their own equipment. Priya Nair, at lane nineteen, did not pretend. She walked the length of the line with her water bottle in her hand, stopped at the proper distance, and said, quite plainly, "I have read the protest. I want you to know that I think it is beneath the competition."
That is kind, Eleanor said.
It is not kind. It is accurate. There is a difference, and at my age I am learning it matters where you spend it. Priya's mouth twitched at her own theft of the phrase, and Eleanor, to Sarah's visible astonishment, allowed the smallest smile to cross her face and be gone.
Tom Keller came next, slower, with his hat in his hands though the sun was already asking for it. He did not offer sympathy, for which Eleanor was grateful. He said, "They inspected my rifle in ninety-eight, at a regional, on a protest from a man who is now selling insurance in Reno. Procedure took four hours. Rifle was fine. He was never fine again, though. Not in his own mind. That's the part they don't tell the young ones when they file these things. Winning one costs you. Losing one costs you more, and different." He put his hat back on. "I'll be in the tent if they'll let me. A witness with grey hair never hurts."