My name is Daniel Bennett. My wife, Leah, and I had lived on Willow Brook Lane for nine years. We bought our house when our daughter, Nora, was still learning to walk. It was the kind of neighborhood where people waved from driveways and returned garbage cans after storms.
At least, that was how it had been before Marla moved in.
Marla Quinn bought the house next door after her divorce. She arrived with a moving truck, two leather couches, six mirrored cabinets, and a white luxury SUV that she parked across the sidewalk. At first, she seemed friendly. She brought us a pie from the grocery store and introduced herself before the moving boxes had even been unloaded.
“I believe neighbors should look out for each other,” she said.
We agreed. We just didn't realize Marla’s definition of looking out for people meant watching everything they owned.
She noticed when we left for work. She knew which days Nora had soccer practice. She knew which delivery companies arrived at which houses. If a box sat outside for more than ten minutes, Marla knew about it.
The first package disappeared in March. It contained a pair of running shoes Leah had ordered for Nora’s thirteenth birthday. The delivery notification included a photograph of the box beside our front door. By the time I came downstairs, it was gone.