I asked Marla if she had seen anyone near our porch. She stood in her doorway wearing a pink bathrobe and holding a cup of coffee.
“No,” she said. “But delivery drivers make mistakes all the time.” “The photograph shows our door.” “Someone probably followed the truck.”
She said it so easily that I believed her. We reported the shoes missing and received a replacement.
Two weeks later, my blood pressure medication disappeared. Our doorbell camera had been offline because of a router update. Marla claimed she had spent the entire morning shopping, but then Nora saw a padded pharmacy envelope inside Marla’s recycling bin. The label had been torn off.
When I confronted her, Marla opened her door only halfway. Her expression hardened instantly.
“You should be more careful about accusing people,” she snapped, before slamming the door in my face. That evening, she posted in the neighborhood social media group, vaguely accusing someone of going through private trash containers. She didn't name me, but she didn't have to.
By summer, packages had begun disappearing from other homes. Mr. Ellison lost a set of hearing-aid batteries. Tanya Brooks, a single mother at the end of the street, lost school uniforms she had purchased during a sale.