The worst was a box containing a handmade quilt that disappeared from Mrs. Delaney’s porch. Her sister had spent six months sewing it. When Mrs. Delaney asked Marla whether she had noticed anything, Marla suggested the quilt had never existed.
“People invent sentimental stories when they want attention,” she told the heartbroken older woman.
That was when I stopped treating the thefts as bad luck. I installed two new cameras: one facing the porch, and the other covering the side yard between our houses. For three weeks, nothing disappeared.
Then a box of dog treats arrived while I was working in the backyard. The package sat outside for exactly eleven minutes. Our camera recorded Marla crossing the lawn, stepping onto our porch, lifting the box, and carrying it home.
I called the police. An officer watched the recording and went next door. Marla effortlessly lied, claiming she had taken the package for "safekeeping" because rain was expected—despite the cloudless sky. Because she handed the unopened box over, the officer only gave her a warning.
That night, she placed the box of dog treats in the center of our porch with a note taped to it:
You’re welcome.
Leah found me staring at the note. “Don’t give her what she wants,” she said. “She wants to make you look angrier than she looks guilty.”