"But here's the truth they don't put on the little cards," he said. "A rifle on a table is a dead thing. A rifle in the mud is history. History" — and he smiled straight out at the bleachers, at the cameras coming up in a scatter of small black rectangles all over the crowd — "history was never, ever clean."
He swung the rifle down.
It was not a fumble, and no one who saw it ever afterwards pretended it was. Julian Hartley swung the Blake family's rifle down in a practised, two-handed arc, the way a man in a film swings a thing he wants the audience to watch fall, and let it go at the bottom of the swing, and the rifle struck the concrete of the firing point hard, butt and barrel, with a crack of wood and a clang of metal that went through the pavilion like a dropped tray in a church. It bounced once, a small, obscene hop, and came to rest on its side in the gritty dust at the edge of the shade, and a puff of pale dust rose up around it and hung in the still air, settling slowly over its dark stock like the first fall of something the day would not be able to shake off.
The crowd made a sound. It was not one sound, because a crowd is not one creature, whatever performers believe. Part of it laughed, the part that had come to be shown something and had been shown something. Part of it gasped. An old woman in the second row put her hand flat to her chest. One of the deputies took half a step forward and then stopped, because nothing in his instructions covered a man in a dress uniform destroying the exhibits, and the half-step hung in the air, unfinished, as evidence that his instinct had been better than his orders. Children, who take their cues from the faces around them, looked from the fallen rifle to their parents and back, deciding whether this was the funny part.
At the officials' table Walter Pruitt's chair scraped. He did not stand this time. He put both of his old hands flat on the table, on either side of Sarah Blake's form, and he looked at the rifle lying in the dust, and his face did something that the people nearest him remembered for years, because it was the face of a man watching a promise he had personally made being broken in public, in sunlight, by a person who was smiling.
Julian stood over the fallen rifle and spread his hands to the crowd, the microphone catching the light. "There she lies!" he called. "That's where she lived, ladies and gentlemen! In the dirt, in the weather, in the hands of boys who hadn't eaten in two days! Not on a table! Not under a card!" He was breathing a little fast. The moment had gone even better than he had rehearsed it in the car that morning, driving in with the uniform jacket hanging from a hook behind his head so it would not crease. In the car he had imagined the throw, the gasp, the laugh, the photograph that would run in the county paper, the young officer bringing history alive. He had not imagined anything after the throw, because in Julian's experience there was never anything after his moments except applause and the next moment, and the world reliably supplied both.
"And the soldier," he said, dropping his voice, walking slowly around the fallen rifle the way a ringmaster walks around a lion he has no respect for, "the soldier did not weep over her, my friends. The soldier picked her up, and he wiped her on his shirt, and he kept walking, because there was a war on. Isn't that right? Isn't that the truth of it?"
He looked down at the rifle in the dust.
Then, unhurriedly, with the timing of a man who has never once in his life been made to pay for a gesture, Julian Hartley lifted one tall, polished brown boot, the boot that had floated the pavilion floor in its shine all morning, and set it down squarely on the fallen rifle, and stood on it.
The boot came down on the wooden stock, over the pale worn place where a thumb had rested ten thousand times, and the old wood, which had been carried through things the crowd in the bleachers could not have named and would not have believed, bore the weight of him without a sound. Dust ground under the sole. Somewhere in the length of the stock there was a small dry creak, not a crack, not a breaking, just the voice a very old thing makes when it is asked to bear one indignity more than it was built for, and Owen Blake, standing at the side of the pavilion with a broom in his hands and the blood making a slow, deafening music in his ears, heard that creak more clearly than he had heard anything all day. It went through him the way a note goes through a wire.