The Second Bench

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Earl nodded slowly. "That's the main one. There's others. 'Could someone check the third case.' That means stand by the cases. 'Is the back room free.' That means call it in, have the doorman watch the street." He turned the earpiece over again. "I asked him who. Who was I supposed to be watching. He said I'd know. Said the associates would make the call, I didn't have to decide anything, I just had to respond. I said, Mr. Lyle, with respect, I've been doing security thirty years, I know what a thief looks like, and it doesn't look like anything. He said this wasn't about thieves. He said it was about the experience. He said our clients paid for a certain experience and part of that experience was not having to share the floor with people who were going to make them uncomfortable."

He stopped.

"And I knew," he said quietly. "Of course I knew. I knew the first time I heard it. Woman came in, Black woman, about my age, nice coat, church hat, she wanted to look at pearls for her granddaughter. And Joan said, 'We have a guest for Earl,' real light, like she was asking for a coffee. And I walked out from my post and I went and stood about eight feet from that woman while she looked at pearls. And she looked up at me. And I looked at her. And she knew what I was doing there, and she knew that I knew. And she put the pearls down and she thanked Joan and she left." He was looking at the earpiece in his hand. "I thought about that woman for a long time. I still think about her."

Simone said nothing. Out on Oak Street a bus went by, and the window hummed slightly in its frame.

"So I did it for a while," Earl said. "Because I needed the job. My wife was sick then. We had insurance through here. I told myself it was just standing. I wasn't doing anything to anybody. I was just standing in a room." He shook his head. "But you can't just stand in a room. Not like that. Not when you look like me and they look like me and everyone in that room knows exactly why you're standing there. You're not just standing. You're the sign on the door."

"And in 2018 you wrote the memo."

"In 2018 my wife passed," Earl said. "And I didn't need the insurance anymore. So I wrote it. Two pages. I said I'd been given verbal instructions to surveil customers based on, I wrote, 'their apparent race,' and that I believed those instructions were discriminatory and possibly illegal, and that I wasn't going to follow them anymore. I sent it to Mr. Lyle and the regional director, Mr. Strand. Mr. Strand wrote back two lines. Said he'd received it and would look into it. That was the last I heard."

"Did you stop?"

Earl was quiet for a moment.

"Mostly," he said. "When somebody called a guest for Earl, I'd go out. Because if I didn't, they'd call the doorman, or they'd call it in to the building, or they'd walk over and do it themselves, and that was worse. But I'd go stand by the door instead of by the customer. And if they looked at me, I'd smile. And sometimes I'd say good afternoon." He paused. "It wasn't enough. I know it wasn't enough. But it was what I had."

"And yesterday?"

He looked up at her.

"Yesterday," he said, "I watched you come in and I knew. Not who you were. I didn't know that. But I knew you weren't going to leave. I could see it in how you walked. And I watched Brooke see you, and I watched her face, and I knew what she was going to do before she did it. And when she said 'we know what our customers look like,' I—" He stopped.

"You said her name," Simone said.

"I was going to say a lot more than her name."

"What were you going to say?"

Earl Tate looked at her for a long moment, this broad gray-haired man in the dark suit with the earpiece in his hand, and then he looked out the window at Oak Street.

"I was going to say," he said, "'Ma'am, I apologize for my colleague. Can I get you a chair while you look at the bracelet.'" He let out a long breath. "That's all. That's all I was going to say. It took me fifteen years to work up to it and when I got there I couldn't do it. I told her Mr. Lyle was coming instead."

The room was very quiet.

"Mr. Tate," Simone said. "My father drove the Number 3 bus on King Drive for thirty-one years. In all that time he never once told a passenger off. Not even the ones who called him names. Not even the ones who spat. He used to say a man in a uniform doesn't get to have opinions. He said the uniform has the opinions and you just wear it." She leaned forward slightly. "He was wrong. And so were you, for a long time. And so was I, for a long time, in different rooms. But you wrote that memo when nobody else in this building would. And you said her name yesterday. That's not nothing. Don't let anybody tell you it's nothing. Including you."

News in the same category

The Second Bench

30 Part