No procedure of this Territory can make a human being into property. The
paper Mr. Hutchins waves is a paper that claims to sell what cannot be sold,
to convey what cannot be conveyed. A sale of a thing that cannot be owned
is not a sale at all. It is void — empty — from the first moment, as if it had
never been written. The law does not recognize it. This court does not
recognize it. It is nothing.
Void. The word hung in the hot air of the courtroom like dust in a sunbeam.
Hutchins made a sound — not a word, a sound, like a man whose chair has
been pulled out from under him while he was still sitting in it. His lawyer put
a hand on his arm, and the mustache had stopped smiling. The judge kept
talking, setting down the rest of it stone by stone: the filings at Prescott,
proper and in order. The two hundred dollars, paid and receipted. The
affidavits from the winter, sworn and witnessed. Each one laid straight, the
way you lay a stone on a wall, until the wall stood and there was nothing on
the other side of it but Hutchins, alone, in his expensive suit.
When it was done, the courtroom exhaled. Tala heard it — a roomful of
people letting go of a breath at the same time, a sound like wind through
cottonwoods. Someone behind her laughed once, short and disbelieving. The
newspaperman's pencil was moving again, fast, as if he were afraid the
words would cool before he caught them. Hutchins sat very still, staring at
nothing, and his lawyer was already gathering papers with the brisk, efficient
movements of a man calculating his fee against a lost cause. Jonah did not
move. He sat with his hands on his knees and looked at the judge the way he
looked at weather: respectfully, from a distance, grateful when it broke in his
favor.
72
Outside, the Tucson sun was white and high, and the plaza's hundred noises
rushed back in like water through a broken dam. Tala stood on the
courthouse steps with the court order in her hands — heavy paper, the
judge's signature black and certain, the territorial seal pressed into the corner
— and looked at it for a long time.
Papers had never meant anything to her. Papers had been the things men
waved while they shouted numbers. Papers had been Hutchins's flag,
snapping in the wind of his own voice. Papers had been the army's excuse,
filed in triplicate.
This paper was different. This paper said what she had said on the ranch
porch in the winter, with the documents held high and the rifles lowered and
her breath smoking in the cold: that she belonged to herself. Only now it was
written down, in ink, with a seal, and men in suits in every office in the
Territory would have to read it and nod and file it away.
She folded it carefully — once, twice, the creases sharp — and put it in the
wooden box, on top of the receipt for two hundred dollars, on top of the
affidavits and the Prescott filings. The receipt had bought the paper. The
paper had bought nothing. That was the joke of it, and the truth of it, and she
almost smiled there on the courthouse steps, in the white sun, with the town
shouting around her. Men had tried to own her with paper; now paper said
they never could. She found the symmetry of it satisfying in a way she did
not try to explain, even to herself.
Jonah was waiting at the bottom of the steps with the horses. He did not ask
how she felt. He only held the box steady while she mounted, and handed it
up to her, and they rode out of Tucson the way they had ridden in — side by
side, saying nothing, the noise of the town falling away behind them mile by
mile until there was only the wind again, and the road, and the wide country
73
opening ahead like a held breath finally let go.
74
Chapter 19
The Choice
They did not talk about the courtroom on the ride home. They talked about
the windmill's loose vane, which needed tightening before the summer
winds, and whether the north pasture wanted reseeding, and a hawk they saw
circling over the ridge, riding the thermals without a single wingbeat.
Ordinary things. Tala found that she liked ordinary things now in a way she
never had before — the way you like water after a long thirst, the way you
like a chair after standing all day.
Days passed at the ranch, and they were good days — the kind of days Tala
had once believed were for other people. She mended a bridle whose
stitching had gone, working the awl through the leather the way her mother
had taught her to work embroidery — patient, even, no stitch shorter than the
last, each one a small promise that the thing would hold. She rode the sorrel
mare to the far fence and back, just to feel the mare's easy gait and to see the
land from its edges, the whole of it laid out like something she was allowed
to love. In the evenings she sat on the porch and watched the light change on
the country, gold to rose to violet, and Jonah sat beside her with his boots on
the rail, and neither of them felt the need to fill the quiet. The quiet was not
75
empty. The quiet was theirs.
Then one morning, over coffee, she told him.
The kitchen smelled of coffee and the bread she had baked the day before.
Jonah sat across from her in his chair, the black coat hung by the door, his
hands around the tin cup. Outside, the windmill turned steadily, repaired.
"I am staying," Tala said.
Jonah looked at her over his cup. He waited. He was good at waiting — it
was one of the first things she had learned about him, the way you learn the
shape of a room by living in it, and one of the things she trusted most.
"Not because I have nowhere else to go," she said. "I have somewhere. I
could go to the eastern mountains, where Mary nursed my mother, and learn
the rest of what Sika never got to teach me. I could go to Tucson and find
work — the court order says I can go anywhere, which is everywhere. I
could ride west until the land runs out." She set her cup down and looked at
him directly. "The house has grown familiar. The horses know me. And the
man beside me never once called me his — not when he bought the paper,
not when the riders came, not once in all the days since."
Jonah was quiet for a long time. The windmill turned. A horse stamped in the
stable.
Then: "Why?"
"Because you gave me the choice," Tala said. "Every day since the auction,
you gave me the choice. The morning after Prescott, you told me I could
leave, and you meant it. You have meant it every day since. And every day, I
stayed." She paused. "That is the whole of it. There is nothing else
underneath."
76
He nodded once. That was all. But something in his face — the war scar
pulling slightly at the corner of his mouth, the way it did when he felt more