The Woman in the Magenta Dress Who Pushed the Old Woman Over the Edge of the Rooftop Terrace

Chapter 28

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The dinner was into its third hour and its third wine when it happened, and it happened, as such things do, inside half a second and out of materials so ordinary that no one ever afterwards agreed entirely on the sequence — which was the whole of Eleanor's point, later, about what she had actually seen.

The girl was working the far side of the table, clearing and pouring in the same pass, a bottle of the good Bordeaux cradled in a napkin in the crook of her arm. Old Mr. Abernathy — eighty-three, deaf in one ear, happy, expansive — pushed his chair back to rise at the exact moment she came behind him, and the chair's top rail caught her elbow. What was never in doubt was the glass: a full glass of red wine went over in a long, slow, irrevocable arc and emptied itself across the front of Bianca Moreau's pale gold dress, across the white cloth, across the silver, in a spreading stain the colour of a wound.

The girl made a small sound. Not a scream — a caught breath, an oh, the first syllable of an apology already forming. She set the bottle down with desperate care on the side table, she had a napkin in her hand — she was turning back toward Bianca with the napkin raised and the apology fully on her lips, she was, in the language of her trade, already in the middle of making it right —

And Bianca stood up, and slapped her across the face.

It was not a wild blow. That, afterwards, was what Eleanor returned to, in the small hours: it was not wild, it was not a flail, it was not the involuntary startle of a woman drenched in cold wine in front of forty people. Bianca rose — she did not lunge, she rose, the way one rises to make a toast — and she struck the girl once, open-palmed, with the full, practiced force of her arm, across the left cheek, hard enough to turn the girl's head on her neck and hard enough that the crack of it went down the table like a shot through the talk, and the talk died, all of it, in one instant, from end to end.

The girl did not fall. She staggered one step, against old Mr. Abernathy's vacated chair, and caught herself, and the napkin stayed in her hand. Her cap had been knocked crooked. A red mark was already rising on her cheek in the print of a hand. She did not touch it. She did not cry out, and she did not — Eleanor saw this with a clarity she would carry to her grave — she did not look around the table for help, which meant that she had never expected any, which meant that this was not, in her experience of the world, an unprecedented event. She straightened her cap with her free hand. She said, "I'm so sorry, madam. It was my fault. I'll fetch — " and she began, of all things, to continue the apology, and then to stoop, automatically, toward the fallen glass.

"Look at it." Bianca's voice was not raised. It was low and bright and carrying, a voice pitched deliberately for the table, and she held the stained front of her dress away from herself with two fingers, like something contaminated. "Look at what she's done. Two thousand dollars of silk, and she can't carry a bottle across a room. In my grandfather's time — " she gave a short, incredulous laugh, and glanced around for the table's agreement — "in my grandfather's time, staff who couldn't do the work were not dressed up in caps and put in front of families like this. They were kept in the kitchen, where their clumsiness couldn't — "

"Bianca." It was Julien, her father, half-risen, crimson. "Bianca, sit — "

"— where it couldn't disgrace a dinner that my family — "

"That will do."

Eleanor had not raised her voice either. She had, in fact, lowered it, and set her glass down on the cloth with a care that forty people heard in the silence like a second, smaller shot. She was looking at Bianca — not at the girl, not at the stain, not at her grandson, whose face, at the first sound of the slap, had gone the colour of paper and whose hand had risen, arrested, halfway across the tablecloth and stayed there, a gesture begun and never completed, which his grandmother noted and filed along with everything else she was filing that night.

She was looking at Bianca, and what she saw was the seam.

It was not the slap itself. Eleanor had seen tempers and blows before, and she did not believe that a single act, however ugly, was a whole person. It was what followed the slap. It was the leisure of it. The standing there, unhurried, holding the stained silk away from her body with two fingers, waiting — actually waiting, with the bright, composed expectation of the wronged — for the room to agree with her. There had been no horror in Bianca's face at what her own hand had done. No startlement, no shame, no wince of the soul at the sound a palm makes on a young girl's face. She had struck a servant, in public, as her grandfather's generation struck them, in the unexamined certainty that the room's sympathy belonged by right to the dress and not the cheek — and the most telling detail of all, the one Eleanor would repeat to exactly one person, once, was that Bianca had glanced first at the guests, and not at the girl. Her audience mattered. The girl, at no point in the entire performance, had.

News in the same category

The Woman in the Magenta Dress Who Pushed the Old Woman Over the Edge of the Rooftop Terrace

45 Part