That night, I lay awake for a while, listening to the house. The wind chime was gone from the porch, taken down after the fine, and the house was quieter without it, which seemed sad in a small way, as if we had given up a small piece of music to keep the peace. I thought about Ava's chalk drawing, which had washed away in the rain long ago, and about the wind chime, and about the visitor fine, and I thought about how small those things were, and how large they had become, because they had taught me to keep records. I thought about June, who had kept newsletters for years without knowing why, and about Sam, who had remembered a garden, and about the Lindqvists, who had answered a stranger's email with plain words. I did not feel brave, exactly. I felt prepared, and prepared was enough, and I fell asleep thinking about the hall on Saturday, and the chairs in rows, and the hope that everyone, including Harold Crane, would be listened to, even if the listening was hard.
Chapter 30: One Hundred and Thirty-Two Residents
On Saturday, the clubhouse hall filled slowly, and then all at once. I arrived early with Tom, and we sat near the middle, not at the front and not at the back, because I did not want to look as if I were leading anything, and I also did not want to hide. June was already there, with her folder, and she was talking quietly to two other long-term residents who would sit with her at the front. The accountant, a calm man with a briefcase and a plain folder of papers, sat to one side, and he did not look nervous, which helped me to feel less nervous myself. Chairs were added at the back, and then more chairs, and I counted without meaning to, and then I stopped counting, because counting felt like a journalist's habit, not a neighbour's habit, and I was there as a neighbour, even if I was only a temporary one.
One hundred and thirty-two residents attended. I know that number because June said it aloud at the start, in her steady voice, and because it was written down in the notes of the meeting, and because it stayed in my mind afterwards as a fact I could hold on to. One hundred and thirty-two people had come, on a Saturday, to a clubhouse hall, to hear about minutes and accounts and a garden that had been gone for nine years. Some of them I knew by name, and some I knew only by sight, and some I had never spoken to at all, and all of them had chosen to be there, which felt, in itself, like a kind of answer to the week before, when people had stopped talking in the street. In a room, at least, they were talking, or ready to listen, and that was a start.
June chaired the residents' side of the meeting. She did not make a speech, and she did not raise her voice. She said that the meeting had been called by a petition signed by one hundred and eighteen residents, to discuss the independent audit, the altered minutes, and the missing fifty-two thousand dollars, and that everyone would be heard, including the board, and that the meeting would stay calm. She said it as if calmness were a rule we had all agreed to, not a hope, and most people seemed to accept it that way. Harold Crane sat at the front with Susan Pike beside him, and Derek Holt stood near the door with his clipboard, and for a moment I thought about all the times that clipboard had arrived at our door, and how different it felt to see it in a room full of people.
The accountant presented first. He spoke plainly, without drama, and he went through his findings in order. He said the garden sale price had been ninety-six thousand dollars, and that only forty-four thousand dollars had reached the community accounts, leaving fifty-two thousand dollars unaccounted for. He said the gate-camera contract for twenty-seven thousand five hundred dollars had been awarded without competitive bids to a firm owned by Crane's nephew, and that the cameras had been installed but never fully connected to the clubhouse system. He did not guess at motives, and he did not use words like theft or fraud. He said what the accounts showed, and what they did not show, and he left the gaps where they were, for the room to see. I wrote the figures in my notebook, even though I already knew them, because writing them down in that room felt like a way of saying that I had heard them, and that they mattered.
Then it was my turn, and my hands were shaking a little as I stood up, and I held my notebook open so that I would not lose my place. I read my statement slowly, the way Tom and I had practiced it, and I looked up between paragraphs, and I saw June nodding, and Tom watching me with a steady expression, and Ava was not there, because she and Leo were at home with a neighbour, and I was glad of that, because I did not want them to hear the tense parts. I read the dates and the fines, and the difference between the newsletter and the minutes, and the accountant's figures, and I ended by saying that I was a temporary resident, that I would leave at the end of February, and that I was speaking not to lead the community, but to share what I had written down, so that the long-term residents could decide for themselves what should happen next. My voice held, mostly, and when I sat down, Tom squeezed my hand under the table, and I felt a rush of relief that was almost like tiredness.