We Rented a House in a Gated Community for Six Months — Then We Found What the Board Had Hidden for Nine Years

Chapter 31

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The second reform was that contracts above five thousand dollars would require two competitive bids. I read that figure twice, too, because it was a figure I had heard before, in the accountant's report, and in the meeting, and now it was written down as a rule, not just as a hope. Two bids would not have prevented every mistake, and June did not claim that it would, but it would have prevented a contract from being awarded quickly, without comparison, to a firm owned by a board member's nephew, and that was enough, for a start. I thought about the gate cameras, installed but never fully connected, and about the money that had been spent on them, and I was glad that the next time a contract of that size came up, someone would have to show two prices, side by side, and explain why one had been chosen.

The third reform was a written fine-appeal process, given to every household. I read it slowly, because this was the reform that touched our own story most directly. It set out, in plain steps, how a resident could appeal a fine, what evidence they could provide, how long the board had to reply, and what would happen if the appeal was accepted. It did not use the language of the old notices, which had been polite but final, and it did not leave the process to be invented each time by whoever happened to be on the board. It was written down, and it was given to everyone, including renters like us, and I felt, reading it, that Ava's chalk drawing and the wind chime and the visitor fine would have been different stories if this process had existed in September. Not necessarily different outcomes, but different conversations, and that, I had learned, was often the most important difference of all.

I received my copy like everyone else, as a renter, and I liked that, too. No one made a special fuss of me, and no one thanked me in the document, and no one singled out our household as an example. The reforms were for the community, not for the Donovans, and that was how it should have been. June had said, at the meeting, that the long-term residents should decide what happened next, and now they had, through the interim board, and I was a recipient, not a leader, and that felt right. I put the reforms in my notebook, at the back, where I kept the most important papers, and I thought about how strange it was that a piece of paper could feel like a kind of safety, when for months pieces of paper, fine notices and refusals, had felt like the opposite.

Ana and Luis came to see us that week, and Ana showed me her copy of the reforms, which she had already read, and she said, with a small laugh, that she was thinking about repainting her front door, in the same color as before, and this time she would appeal if anyone fined her, because now she would know how. Luis smiled, and said he was not sure about the door, but he was sure about the process, and that was enough. We drank tea, and we talked about ordinary things, about school and work and the playground, and I realised that the reforms had done something I had not quite expected: they had made it possible to talk about doors and playgrounds again, without every conversation turning back to fines and minutes and missing money. The dispute had not disappeared, but it had been given a shape, and a shape can be lived with, in a way that a shapeless worry cannot.

Chapter 35: The Fines, Reviewed

The interim board reviewed recent fines, and ours were among them, and I waited for the outcome with a feeling I had not expected, which was not excitement, but a kind of calm curiosity. I had spent months writing down fines, and appealing one of them, and keeping copies, and now someone else was going to look at them, with a process, and I did not know what they would decide, and I tried to be ready for any fair outcome, even if it was not the outcome I might have wished for in September. Tom said that was the right attitude, and that fairness does not always mean getting everything back, and I agreed, though a part of me still thought about the seventy-five dollars and the one hundred and fifty dollars, and about how they had felt, at the time, like small injustices that added up.

The decision, when it came, was clear and, I thought, fair. The Donovans' two hundred dollar visitor fine was withdrawn, because our registration form for Tom's brother had been stamped and dated, and the interim board accepted that the registration had been made properly, and that the fine should never have been issued. I felt a rush of vindication when I read that, not because of the money, although two hundred dollars is not nothing, but because it meant that a piece of paper I had kept, a stamped form in my notebook, had been believed, and that keeping records had mattered. Tom read the letter too, and he nodded, and he said that was exactly what a process should do, and I agreed, and I put the letter in my notebook, next to the original fine notice, so that the two papers would sit together, as a record of a mistake and its correction.

The seventy-five dollar chalk fine and the one hundred and fifty dollar wind-chime fine were not refunded. I read that part twice, slowly, because I wanted to be sure I had understood it, and because I wanted to be honest with myself about how I felt. The interim board said that those fines had been issued under the rules as they stood at the time, and that the rules, however strict, had been the rules, and that refunding every fine issued under them would not be practical, or fair to everyone else who had paid. Instead, the two fines were recorded as examples in the new appeal guidance, so that future residents could see how chalk drawings and wind chimes had been treated, and how the new process would handle similar cases differently. I sat with that for a while, and I thought about Ava's drawing, washed away in the rain, and about the wind chime, taken down from the porch, and I felt a small ache, but not anger, because the decision had been explained, and because it had been made in the open, and because it treated us like everyone else, not better and not worse.

News in the same category

We Rented a House in a Gated Community for Six Months — Then We Found What the Board Had Hidden for Nine Years

45 Part