We Rented a House in a Gated Community for Six Months — Then We Found What the Board Had Hidden for Nine Years

Chapter 28

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

June then read the Lindqvists' words aloud. She did not name them, because they had given permission to share their words anonymously, and she read them slowly, in their plain language, about how they had questioned the garden sale, and how they had been fined repeatedly in the months that followed, and how they had chosen to move rather than keep fighting. The room was very quiet while she read, quieter than it had been for the accountant, because those words were not figures, they were a story, and everyone in the room could imagine themselves in it, staying or leaving, fighting or giving up. When June finished, she folded the paper and put it back in her folder, and she thanked the Lindqvists, even though they were not there, and she thanked everyone for listening, and the meeting moved on, calmly, to Harold Crane's answer.

Chapter 31: Crane's Answer

Harold Crane stood up slowly, and for a moment I thought about how many times I had seen him at board meetings, polite in public, brisk with questions, fond of saying that rules keep a community safe and valuable. He looked older that Saturday than he had looked at the regular meeting I had observed months before, and his suit was neat, as always, but his hands rested on the table in front of him as if he needed the table to steady them. He thanked June for chairing, and he thanked the residents for coming, and he said that he understood why people had questions, and that he wanted to answer them. I tried to listen the way I had listened to the accountant, without deciding in advance what I would think, because fairness, I had learned that winter, meant listening even when listening was uncomfortable.

Crane spoke at length. He said the garden sale had been approved, and that the community had agreed to it at the time, and that the minutes reflected that agreement. He said the missing money was a bookkeeping error, a matter of entries made in the wrong place at the wrong time, and that it would be corrected when the accounts were properly reconciled. He said the camera contract had been urgent, because the community had needed security, and that was why it had been awarded quickly, without the usual process, to a firm he trusted. He spoke calmly, and he did not shout, and he did not blame anyone by name, and I could see why he had been board president for so long. He sounded reasonable, and he sounded sure, and for a few minutes I wondered whether the room would accept his answers and go home.

But as he went on, I noticed what he did not produce. He did not produce the original minutes, the ones that would have shown the discussion as it actually happened. He did not produce the full sale documents, the ones that would have shown where the ninety-six thousand dollars had gone, step by step. He did not produce a second bid for the camera contract, or any record of a competitive process, or any explanation of why the cameras, once installed, had never been fully connected to the clubhouse system. He said the words bookkeeping error and urgent several times, as if repeating them would make them into evidence, and he said that the community's finances were, in general, in good order, but he did not show the room the papers that would have proved it. I wrote that down, too, in my notebook, not as a judgment, but as a fact: no original minutes produced, no full sale documents produced, no second bid produced.

The room listened, and the listening was polite, but it was not settled. I could feel it in the way people shifted in their chairs, and in the way no one clapped or murmured agreement, and in the way June, at the front, kept her face calm and her pen ready. A resident near the back asked, quietly, whether the original minutes could be shown to the residents, and Crane said they were archived, and that they would take time to retrieve, which was the same answer the board had given me months before, when I had written my calm, factual letter. Another resident asked about the cameras, and why they had never been connected, and Crane said the system had needed further work, and that the work had been delayed, but he did not say when it would be finished, or who would finish it, or what it would cost. The answers were long, and they were polite, and they did not settle the questions, and after a while I stopped expecting them to.

I looked at Susan Pike beside him, and she was very still, with her hands folded, and she did not speak during Crane's answer. I thought about the locked cabinet in the clubhouse office, where she kept the community accounts, and about how much of this story had lived in cabinets and archives and rooms that residents could not easily enter. I did not feel anger towards her in that moment, which surprised me. I felt something closer to sadness, because a community is not a bank, and accounts are not private property, and yet for years the accounts had been treated as if they belonged to the board, not to the people who paid into them. Crane finished by saying that he had served Stonebridge for many years, and that he had always acted in its best interests, and that he hoped the residents would remember that. He sat down, and the room was quiet, and June thanked him for his answer, and said that the meeting would now consider what should happen next.

News in the same category

We Rented a House in a Gated Community for Six Months — Then We Found What the Board Had Hidden for Nine Years

45 Part