What the Agent Recorded on Cinder Hollow Road

Chapter 31

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Dana Whitfield testified next, thirty-nine years old, the dispatcher, and she walked into the courtroom with a folder in her hands, and she took the oath, and she told the jury who she was, and how long she had worked as a dispatcher in Dry Creek County, and about the duplicate log she kept at home, in a drawer, a second copy of every dispatch, every stop, every tow, every call, kept because she had learned that the official log could be changed, and that the duplicate could not. She opened the folder, and she showed the jury the entries for the night of my stop, nine-fourteen, Cinder Hollow Road, the tow, the booking, the nurse at two-forty, the medication at three-thirty-five, the phone call at five-fifteen, all in her own handwriting, all with times that matched my notes, and my recordings, and Harold's dashcam, and the telematics, and she told the jury that the official log, the one in the sheriff's office, did not match, that the stop was missing, that the tow was missing, that the times had been changed, and that she had noticed the gap, the morning after my release, when she came back on shift and looked at the log, and saw that what she had written was not what was there. The prosecutor asked her why she had kept a duplicate log, and she said, quietly, that she had kept it because she had watched, for years, as stops were logged and then erased, and as motorists were towed and charged and made to pay, and that she had known, each time, that the log she was writing would be changed, or ignored, or lost, and that the duplicate, in her drawer, was the only true record, and that one day, someone would need it, and that day had come. The defence lawyer asked her if she was angry at the sheriff, or if she had a grudge, or if she had made up the log, and she answered, calmly, that she was not angry, that she had no grudge, that she had written the log at the time, in her own handwriting, and that the jury could compare it to the official log, and see for themselves, and he sat down, and she stepped down, and I watched her leave the courtroom, and I felt grateful, because Dana Whitfield, thirty-nine, dispatcher, had done a brave thing, and her bravery, like Harold's, had changed the case.

Harold Finch testified after Dana, sixty-nine years old, retired school-bus driver, and he walked into the courtroom slowly, with a small drive in his hand, and he took the oath, and he told the jury who he was, and how long he had driven a school bus, forty years, and about the dashcam in his car, and about the Tuesday night in late September when he had been driving home behind me on Cinder Hollow Road, late, after visiting his sister, and about the dark-green Subaru ahead of him, steady in its lane, on a straight stretch, with both taillights working, bright and clear, and about the patrol car that pulled out and stopped me, and about the way he had driven past, slowly, and kept his dashcam running, and about the way he had watched the footage when he got home, and saved it, because he had thought, even then, that something was not right. The prosecutor played the dashcam footage for the jury, on a large screen, and the courtroom watched, in silence, as my Subaru drove down Cinder Hollow Road, steady, in its lane, taillights working, centre line unbroken, and as the patrol car pulled out behind it, and the red and blue lights came on, and I pulled over, calmly, onto a safe shoulder, and the jury watched, and I watched them watch, and I saw them nod, and I saw them write notes, and I knew that the dashcam, more than any testimony, was proving the case, because a picture, moving and clear, taken by a stranger with no reason to lie, is the hardest thing in the world to argue with. The defence lawyer asked Harold if he was sure about what he had seen, if he could have been mistaken, if the taillights could have been reflections, if the centre line could have been crossed for a moment he did not see, and Harold answered, slowly, that he had driven a school bus for forty years, that he knew how to watch a road, that he had watched that road that night, that he had seen my car, steady, in its lane, with both taillights working, and that he was sure, and he sat down, and the prosecutor thanked him, and Harold stepped down, and I thanked him, in my heart, for driving home behind me that night, and for keeping his dashcam running, and for keeping the footage, and for being willing to tell the truth in a courtroom, at sixty-nine years old, when it would have been easier to stay home and say nothing.

News in the same category

What the Agent Recorded on Cinder Hollow Road

45 Part