The judge sentenced Sheriff Cole Ashford first, fifty-eight years old, nineteen years in office, and he sentenced him to seven years in federal prison, five years to serve, two years suspended, plus probation, plus five hundred hours of community service, and he ordered him removed from office, immediately, and Ashford stood, and listened, and said nothing, and I watched him, and I thought about the night on Cinder Hollow Road, when he had stood at my window, and said his word was the law, and I thought about how his word, that night, had seemed like law, and how, in this courtroom, on this grey morning, the law had spoken back, in numbers, seven years, five to serve, two suspended, probation, five hundred hours, removed from office, and I felt, not triumph, but a quiet sense that the law, when it works, works slowly, and carefully, and that slowness, and care, are what make it just. The judge sentenced Deputy Grant Hollis next, thirty-three years old, to three years, two years to serve, one year suspended, plus probation, and Hollis stood, and listened, and looked down, and I thought about the porch visit, in the late afternoon, when he had told me to drop the complaint, and about the flashlight in my window, and about the false claims, crossing the centre line, one taillight out, and I thought about how a man of thirty-three, who had followed orders for years, had now been given a sentence of his own, and that the sentence, three years, two to serve, one suspended, was a price for following, and for lying, and for intimidating a witness on her own porch.
The judge sentenced Deputy Frank Calloway next, fifty-one years old, the jailer, to two years suspended, plus probation, plus two hundred and fifty hours of community service, and Calloway stood, and listened, and I thought about the booking room, and the inventory form, and the one thousand one hundred and fifty dollars omitted, and the medication denied until three-thirty-five, and the phone call denied until five-fifteen, and the times he had told me to wait, again and again, and I thought about how a suspended sentence, two years, plus probation, plus two hundred and fifty hours, was a recognition that his crimes were serious, but that he had not been the leader, he had been a follower, and that following, in a jail, where a woman is asking for her asthma medication, is still a crime, when the following means denying medicine to someone who needs it, and denying a phone call to someone who has a right to it. The judge sentenced Ray Sutton last, fifty-five years old, of Sutton's Towing, to eighteen months suspended, plus a five-year ban on county towing contracts, plus his licence suspended for two years, and Sutton stood, and listened, and I thought about the tow truck on Cinder Hollow Road, and the invoice for nine hundred dollars, six hundred and forty dollars impound, two hundred and sixty dollars storage, and about the duplicate invoices, forty-four thousand dollars, and about the way he had not looked at me, that night, and I thought about how a five-year ban, and a licence suspended for two years, would end his business in Dry Creek County, and that, more than the suspended sentence, was the consequence that mattered, because a tow operator who bills twice, and who works only for a sheriff who calls him at night, cannot continue to work, when the sheriff is removed, and the contract is ended, and the county votes, four to one, to require body cameras, and an outside jail-log audit, and to end the Sutton towing contract, for good.
The judge then turned to restitution, and he ordered it, clearly, and in full, and I listened, and I wrote the numbers down, in my notebook, as he spoke them, because numbers, in a courtroom, are the clearest form of justice, and because I wanted to remember them exactly, without mistake. He ordered restitution of two hundred and eighty-one thousand five hundred dollars to a victims' fund, for the twenty motorists, over three years, in addition to my own personal restitution, and he ordered my personal restitution, twenty-one thousand four hundred dollars in total, made up of one thousand one hundred and fifty dollars in cash, nine hundred dollars in tow and storage, and nineteen thousand three hundred and fifty dollars in medical, travel and legal costs, and I listened, and I felt tears in my eyes, not because of the money, though the money mattered, but because the numbers, spoken aloud by a judge, meant that the court had believed me, and had believed the twenty motorists, and had counted what had been taken, and had ordered it to be given back. One thousand one hundred and fifty dollars, plus nine hundred dollars, plus nineteen thousand three hundred and fifty dollars, equals twenty-one thousand four hundred dollars, and two hundred and eighty-one thousand five hundred dollars, in addition, to the victims' fund, and together, those numbers told a story, a story about a scheme that had taken money, and about a court that had ordered it returned, and about a county that would, in time, pay it back, not just in dollars, but in reform, and in accountability, and in the knowledge that what had happened would not be forgotten, and would not be repeated, if the reforms held.