After Harold, the prosecutor called Agent Miriam Solano, forty-three, from the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency, and she walked into the courtroom with a thick file, and she took the oath, and she told the jury about the investigation she had opened, with Daniel Okafor, after Dana gave him her duplicate log, and about the evidence she had gathered, the dashcam, the telematics, the taillight records, the Sutton invoices, the booking logs, the inventory forms, the cash seizure records, and the interviews with the twenty motorists, over three years, who had been stopped on empty roads at night, searched without cause, towed by Sutton's, billed for impound and storage, and, in many cases, relieved of cash that was never listed. She told the jury the total, two hundred and eighty-one thousand five hundred dollars, across twenty motorists, over three years, and she told them about the duplicate Sutton invoices, forty-four thousand dollars of them, the same tow billed twice, and about the unlogged cash seizures, thirty-one thousand seven hundred dollars, cash taken from bags and wallets and pockets, never listed, never returned, never accounted for, cash like my one thousand one hundred and fifty dollars, omitted from my booking inventory. She showed the jury the invoices, laid out on a table, with duplicates highlighted, and she showed them the inventory forms, with blank spaces where cash should have been listed, and she showed them the dispatch logs, official and duplicate, side by side, with gaps in the official log where the duplicate log had entries, and the jury looked, and wrote notes, and I watched them, and I knew that the pattern, laid out in paper, was proving what my story, alone, could not prove, that my stop was not an exception, but an example, and that the scheme was systematic, and deliberate, and worth two hundred and eighty-one thousand five hundred dollars.
The prosecutor then called an expert on Subaru telematics, who explained to the jury, in plain language, how the telematics worked, how the car recorded its position, its speed, its lane, its lights, second by second, and how the records for my dark-green 2021 Subaru Outback showed, on the Tuesday night in late September, at nine-fourteen, on Cinder Hollow Road, that I had stayed in my lane, that I had driven at the speed limit, that I had not crossed the centre line, and that both taillights had been working, all night, all day, that morning, when I had checked them, and that evening, when I had driven to Mrs. Delgado's house. He showed the jury the taillight records, separate from the telematics, showing both taillights tested and working, with no fault recorded, before or after the stop, and he told them that the claim of one taillight out was false, and that the claim of crossing the centre line was false, and that a stop based on false claims is not a lawful stop. The defence lawyer asked him if telematics could be wrong, if a sensor could fail, if a record could be misread, and the expert answered, calmly, that telematics, like a dashcam, like a log kept in duplicate, is a record, and that records, when they agree, as the dashcam and the telematics and the log agreed in this case, are very hard to argue with, and he sat down, and the jury wrote notes, and I felt, sitting in the courtroom, that the case was strong, and that the evidence, laid out piece by piece, was building a wall that the defence could not climb over, no matter how hard they tried.
The defence case was short, and it was, in its way, predictable. Ashford's lawyer called Ashford himself, fifty-eight, nineteen years in office, and Ashford took the stand, and he told the jury that he had been sheriff for nineteen years, and that he had served the county faithfully, and that the stop on Cinder Hollow Road had been a routine traffic stop, based on a centre-line violation and a taillight, and that my refusal to consent to a search had been obstruction, and that the arrest had been lawful, and that the tow had been routine, and that the booking had been routine, and that any mistakes in the inventory, or the medical log, or the phone log, were clerical errors, not crimes, and that the duplicate invoices were billing errors, not fraud, and that the unlogged cash was a misunderstanding, not theft. He spoke calmly, and he looked at the jury, and he tried to sound like a sheriff, a man of authority, a man who had held an office for nineteen years, and who deserved to be believed, and for a moment, I wondered if the jury would believe him, because nineteen years is a long time, and authority is a powerful thing, and a man in a suit, speaking calmly, can sound convincing, even when the evidence says otherwise. Then the prosecutor stood up, and he cross-examined Ashford, and he asked him about the dashcam, and about the telematics, and about the duplicate log, and about the invoices, and about the cash, and about the nurse at two-forty, and the medication at three-thirty-five, and the phone call at five-fifteen, and about the visit Hollis had made to my porch, in the late afternoon, telling me to drop the complaint, and Ashford's answers grew shorter, and less certain, and he said he did not remember, and he did not know, and it was not his responsibility, and it was someone else's job, and the jury watched, and wrote notes, and I watched them, and I knew that the wall of evidence was holding, and that Ashford, for all his nineteen years, could not climb over it.