He thought about the six photographs on the table in the interview room, and about the way Camille had laid them out one after another, and about the way Sheila had answered each question with an excuse that had worked on the street for months and did not work in that room at all. On the street, the excuses worked because nobody was keeping score. In the interview room, someone was keeping score, and the score was written in photographs, in messages, in envelopes, in notebooks. Sheila had kept her own records. The network had kept its own records. And now Camille was laying both sets of records on the same table, and the woman who had believed she was smarter than everyone was learning that she had been the easiest person in the neighborhood to read.
The search happened the next morning. Grant stood across the street while officers carried boxes out of Sheila's house, and he watched the way he had watched the interview recording, looking for the line where the numbers stopped adding up. He had been awake since before dawn, standing at his kitchen window watching the cruisers arrive one after another, watching the officers walk up her steps, watching the door open and close. He did not cross the street. Lena had told him to stay where he was. He stayed, and he watched, and the morning went on, and the boxes kept coming out.
The garage held property from more than forty deliveries. Some boxes were unopened, stacked in neat rows against the wall, the labels still attached, the tape still sealed. Others had been emptied into plastic bins: children's shoes, prescription supplies, kitchen equipment, birthday gifts, phone accessories, books, tools. The officers carried the bins out one at a time and set them on the driveway, and Grant stood across the street and tried to match the things in them to the houses they had come from. He recognized some of it. He recognized the shape of a birthday gift he had seen a neighbor carry inside months earlier, the paper torn at one corner, the ribbon still tied. He recognized a set of tools that belonged to a man three doors down, the kind of tools a mechanic keeps in a case with his name written on the handle in permanent marker. He recognized a pair of children's shoes, small, scuffed at the toes, the kind a mother buys for a child who outgrows them in a season. It was his street, carried out of her garage in pieces, and he stood there with his hands in his pockets and felt something he had not expected to feel. It was not anger. Anger had already had its turn, on the porch, in the second confrontation, in the months of watching his packages disappear. What he felt now was smaller and heavier, the recognition that the woman across the street had been running a business out of other people's lives, and that the business had been running longer than anyone had guessed.
He thought about the forty deliveries, and about the months they had spanned, and about the way Sheila had kept the garage organized, the unopened boxes in rows, the emptied goods sorted into bins, the labels filed or discarded according to some system only she understood. It was not the garage of a woman who took things on impulse. It was the garage of a woman who had built a routine around taking things, who had learned which houses to visit and when, who had kept track of what sold and what did not, who had turned the porches of Hawthorne Park into a supply line. He had lived across the street from that garage for years. He had waved to her at cleanups. He had listened to her complain about barking dogs. He had never once imagined what was behind the door.
Other neighbors stood on their own porches that morning, watching the same thing Grant was watching, and he could see their faces change the way his own must have changed. Some of them had filed reports. Some of them had lost things they never got back. Some of them had stood on Sheila's steps and listened to her excuses and walked away feeling unreasonable for having asked. Now they watched officers carry bins out of her garage, and the excuses fell apart in daylight, one box at a time. Grant thought about the safety meetings Sheila had attended, every one of them, sitting in the front row with her notebook open, nodding while the officers talked about package theft, and he understood that she had not been attending those meetings to help. She had been attending them to learn what the police knew, and what they did not, and how much room she still had to operate.