In the days that followed, Grant started paying attention in a way he had not paid attention before. He noticed the rhythm of the street, the way deliveries arrived in the late morning and the early afternoon, the way the vans turned onto Hawthorne Avenue and stopped and started again. He noticed that Sheila's front door opened more often than it used to, and that she stood on her porch longer than she used to, and that she seemed to be watching the street with a focus that had nothing to do with barking dogs or neighborhood cleanups. He did not confront her. Not yet. He had no proof, and he had learned in his accounting office that an accusation without proof was worse than no accusation at all, because it warned the person you were accusing and gave them time to prepare.
He talked to Mrs. Alvarez again, and to Tom Bell, and to Keisha Moore, and he listened to their stories the way he listened to a client explaining a discrepancy in a ledger, patiently, without interrupting, writing down the details that mattered. Mrs. Alvarez told him she had once seen Sheila carrying a box that looked like the one she had lost, and when she had asked about it Sheila had said the label was wet and she had thought it was hers, and Mrs. Alvarez had let it go because she did not want a fight with a neighbor. Tom Bell told him he had found an empty box beside his trash cans one morning, the label removed, and he had thrown it away without thinking about it, and now he wished he had kept it. Keisha Moore told him she had watched Sheila from her window one afternoon, carrying a parcel across the street, and she had told herself she was imagining things, because why would a woman in a bright cardigan steal baby formula.
Grant wrote all of it down. He wrote down the dates, or as close to the dates as his neighbors could remember them. He wrote down the descriptions of the boxes. He wrote down the excuses Sheila had given, because the excuses were a pattern too, and patterns were what he understood best. A single missing package could be a mistake. A single excuse could be a misunderstanding. But seven months of missing packages, and the same woman, and the same excuses, and the same empty boxes appearing beside trash cans with the labels removed, was not a mistake. It was a system, and Grant had spent his working life finding systems inside numbers that did not add up.
He also thought about the photograph box, and about what it meant to lose it. The photographs had been damaged once already, in the basement flood, and the restoration company had saved them, and now they were gone again, and this time there was no company that could bring them back. He thought about Hannah before the illness, laughing, holding Sophie up in the air, and he thought about the beach photograph, Hannah holding Sophie's hand at the edge of the water, and he thought about all the small moments that had been captured in those pictures, moments that existed now only in his memory and in Sophie's memory, and he felt the loss in a way that was physical. He did not blame himself for being at the grocery store. He blamed the person who had taken the box, and he blamed the neighborhood for letting her take it, and he blamed himself a little for not having seen it sooner, because the signs had been there for months and he had walked past them the way everyone else had.
Grant ran a small accounting office out of a converted storefront three blocks from his house, and his working life had taught him to trust paper more than memory. A number that did not balance was not a mystery. It was a fact waiting to be found, and the way to find it was to write down everything, in order. He kept his clients' ledgers the same way he kept his own life, in folders, labeled, dated, cross-referenced, and he had learned that most problems announced themselves long before anyone noticed them, in small discrepancies that were easy to ignore. A dollar missing here. A receipt that did not match there. A package that never arrived. He had ignored the first missing package, the door hinges, because a box of hinges was small and the delivery company had offered to send another one, and he had told himself that mistakes happened. He had ignored the second, the sweater, because he had been busy at the office and because Sophie had been the one who noticed it first, and he had not wanted to make her feel worse about it than she already did. By the third, the hard drive, he had started a folder. By the fourth, he had started a list.