But refusing to show a customer a piece of jewelry because the manager had not decided the customer was worth the effort was something else entirely.
And if Vanessa Whitfield had made that decision once, Alicia wanted to know how often she had made it before.
THE REPORTS THAT DISAPPEARED
At 4:27 p.m., Alicia sat in the back of a black sedan parked on a quiet side street.
She had removed the floral arrangement from her hair and placed it carefully beside her clutch.
Her phone was connected to the vehicle's conference system.
A digital folder was open on the screen.
The first person to join the call was Daniel Reeves, the chief operating officer of Prestige Holdings.
Daniel had worked in luxury retail for twenty-two years. He had joined the company before the acquisition and had remained through the transition because Alicia believed institutional knowledge was valuable.
He was intelligent.
He was practical.
And he had a tendency to believe that most problems could be solved through better reporting.
Alicia liked that about him.
Sometimes she also had to remind him that reporting systems did not always reveal the truth.
“Good afternoon,” Daniel said.
“Good afternoon.”
“Are you still in Beverly Hills?”
“Yes.”
“Did you visit the boutique?”
“I did.”
A pause followed.
“How was it?”
Alicia looked through the window.
“Interesting.”
Daniel gave a small laugh.
“That's not usually a good sign.”
“Not always.”
“Did you meet Vanessa?”
“Yes.”
“Vanessa Whitfield?”
“That's right.”
Daniel tapped something on his keyboard.
“She has been with the company for seven years. Store manager for three.”
“I know.”
“Her numbers are strong.”
Alicia looked down at the report.
“Are they?”
“Revenue is above the regional average. Client retention is good. Her team has consistently met the quarterly targets.”
“Those are the numbers I saw.”
“Then what concerns you?”
Alicia leaned back.
“Daniel, how do we measure whether a customer receives appropriate service?”
“We have several indicators. Customer satisfaction surveys, repeat business, conversion rate, complaint volume, and mystery-shopper evaluations.”
“Do we measure who receives access to merchandise?”
“We track presentations.”
“Do we measure who is denied a presentation?”
Daniel paused.
“Not directly.”
“Do we record why a presentation is declined?”
“Associates can enter notes.”
“Are those notes mandatory?”
“Not in every case.”
“Can a manager override an associate's decision to present a piece?”
“Yes.”
“Is the reason for the override recorded?”
“Sometimes.”
Alicia looked at the screen.
“That's a lot of sometimes.”
Daniel did not respond.
A second participant joined.
Priya Shah, the company's general counsel.
“Good afternoon,” she said.
“Good afternoon, Priya.”
“I understand we're discussing Beverly Hills.”
“We are.”
Priya's voice became more focused.
“Has there been a formal complaint?”
“Not yet.”
“Has a customer alleged discriminatory treatment?”
Alicia considered the question.
“I haven't filed a complaint. I visited the store and experienced a service interaction that raised questions.”
“Understood.”
Priya paused.
“May I ask what happened?”
Alicia described the visit.
She explained the champagne service, the delay, the questions about appointments, the refusal to show the bracelet without establishing purchasing intent, and Vanessa's decision to redirect Claire.
She did not exaggerate.
She did not speculate about Vanessa's motives.
She described what she had seen and what had been said.
When she finished, Priya was quiet.
Daniel spoke first.
“Did Vanessa know who you were?”
“No.”
“Did anyone at the store recognize you?”
“Not that I could tell.”
“Did you identify yourself?”
“No.”
“Then she may have thought you were simply browsing.”
“Browsing is not misconduct.”
“Of course not.”
“Neither is asking to see a bracelet.”
“No.”
Alicia looked at the report again.
“Did the Beverly Hills store receive any complaints about selective service during the last year?”
Daniel opened another file.
“We had three complaints categorized under customer experience.”
“Only three?”
“Three formal complaints.”
“What were they about?”
“One customer said an associate refused to show her a limited-edition necklace. Another said she was repeatedly redirected to the lower-priced collections. The third involved a customer who believed she had been followed by security.”
“Were those complaints investigated?”
“They were closed.”
“By whom?”
Daniel hesitated.
“Two were closed by the store. One was reviewed by the district office.”
“Were the customers interviewed?”
“I'd have to check.”
“Please do.”
Daniel began typing.
Priya spoke.
“I would like the original records preserved before anyone contacts the store.”
“Agreed,” Alicia said.
Daniel nodded, although she could only hear the movement of his chair.
“I'll issue a preservation notice to the information team.”
“Not to the store.”
“Understood.”
Alicia continued.
“I want the raw records, not just the summaries.”
“Which records?”
“Customer complaints, internal notes, appointment histories, presentation logs, manager overrides, security incident reports, and customer follow-up records.”
Daniel typed.
“Anything else?”