Some complaints were missing.
Others had been marked as resolved without evidence that the customer had been contacted.
A number of reports had been closed using identical language.
Alicia had asked her chief operating officer, Marcus Reed, to investigate.
Marcus had suggested beginning with the Beverly Hills flagship.
It was one of the company's most important stores.
It had the highest average transaction value in the western region.
It also had one of the lowest formal complaint rates.
On paper, the location appeared to be among the best-performing boutiques in the company.
But the internal customer comments told a different story.
Alicia had decided to visit without announcing herself.
She had not expected the first interaction to be perfect.
She had expected to see whether the staff followed the basic service standards when they did not recognize the customer.
The result had been worse than she anticipated.
And the champagne had become more than a small courtesy.
It had become a visible symbol of a much larger question.
Who did the boutique believe deserved to be welcomed?
A black sedan pulled up beside the curb.
The driver stepped out.
"Good afternoon, Ms. Monroe."
Alicia smiled.
"Hello, James."
He opened the rear door.
"How was the luncheon?"
"Good."
"Everything all right?"
"Yes."
She entered the car.
James closed the door and returned to the driver's seat.
As the sedan pulled away, Alicia looked through the window at Prestige & Co.
The boutique grew smaller.
She watched until the building disappeared behind a row of trees.
Then she opened her phone again.
This time, she called Marcus Reed.
He answered after two rings.
"Marcus."
"Hello."
"How did the luncheon go?"
"Well."
"Are you still in Beverly Hills?"
"Just leaving."
There was a short pause.
"Did you visit the flagship?"
"Yes."
Marcus became attentive.
"And?"
Alicia looked down at her notes.
"I want the original customer-service reports for the last eighteen months."
Marcus was silent for a moment.
"All of them?"
"Every complaint, every manager response, every closure note, and every escalation record."
"That's a significant volume."
"I know."
"Did something happen?"
Alicia looked out the window.
"Yes."
"What?"
"I was treated as though I didn't belong in a store my company controls."
Marcus did not answer immediately.
Then he asked:
"Did they recognize you?"
"Eventually."
"Eventually?"
"After Vanessa Whitfield entered my phone number into the system."
Marcus exhaled.
"That's not good."
"No."
"Did you tell her who you were?"
"No."
"Did she find out through the customer profile?"
"Yes."
"And then?"
"Then I became important enough for champagne."
Marcus was quiet.
Alicia continued.
"I want the original records. Not the regional summaries. I want to know how many customers experienced the same thing."
"Understood."
"Also, don't call Vanessa yet."
"All right."
"Don't alert the regional director. Don't announce an investigation. Don't let the store know that corporate is reviewing them."
Marcus paused.
"Do you want an independent review?"
"Yes. But first I want the records preserved."
"I'll contact legal."
"Good."
Marcus lowered his voice.
"Alicia, if this is connected to the complaints we've been reviewing, we need to be careful. The company has obligations to employees as well as customers."
"I know."
"We shouldn't reach conclusions before we have the facts."
"I'm not asking you to."
"Good."
Alicia looked at the passing buildings.
"I'm asking you to find the facts."
Marcus understood.
"All right. I'll begin with the records."
"Thank you."
She ended the call.
For a moment, she sat quietly.
Then she opened another contact.
Naomi Ellis.
The company's general counsel.
Alicia sent a short message.
Please prepare a preservation notice covering customer complaints, service records, appointment logs, employee schedules, and manager communications for the Beverly Hills location. Do not circulate it beyond the necessary legal and records personnel until we discuss the scope.
A reply came less than a minute later.
Understood. Is there an urgent incident?
Alicia typed:
Potential pattern of inconsistent customer treatment. I will explain in person.
She put the phone down.
The car continued toward her home.
But Alicia's thoughts remained at the boutique.
She was thinking about Daniel.
The young associate had looked uncomfortable.
He had been placed in a difficult position by a manager who expected him to follow her lead.
Alicia did not know whether he had witnessed similar interactions before.
She did not know whether he had tried to challenge them.
She did not know whether he feared losing his job.
Those questions mattered.
If the investigation focused only on Vanessa, it might identify one manager's behavior without understanding the culture that had allowed it.
Alicia wanted to know how the boutique operated when the owner was absent.
She wanted to know what employees were rewarded for.