“Training materials. Store-level service guidelines. Any documents explaining who qualifies for private presentations.”
Priya added:
“Include document revision history and access logs where available.”
Alicia nodded.
“Good.”
Daniel paused.
“Can I ask something?”
“Of course.”
“Are we looking at one manager's conduct or a wider issue?”
“I don't know yet.”
“Then perhaps we should be careful about treating this as an investigation before we understand the facts.”
Alicia looked out the window.
“That's exactly why I want the facts.”
She ended the call twenty minutes later.
For the next two hours, she reviewed the preliminary customer-experience report.
The report had been prepared by a small internal team led by Marcus Ellison, vice president of customer standards.
Marcus had joined Prestige Holdings four months after the acquisition.
He was careful, analytical, and not especially interested in pleasing senior executives.
Alicia trusted him.
His report contained no dramatic conclusions.
It did not accuse any employee of deliberate discrimination.
It did not suggest that every difference in service represented wrongdoing.
Instead, it identified patterns that required further examination.
The most significant section was titled:
Access to High-Value Merchandise: Preliminary Observations
Alicia read it slowly.
Across twenty-three locations, the company had recorded more than 18,000 presentations of merchandise valued above $25,000 during the previous twelve months.
The data showed that customers with existing purchase histories were more likely to receive immediate presentations.
That was expected.
What was less expected was the difference among first-time visitors.
Some received private consultations within minutes.
Others were asked to provide appointments, purchasing plans, or budget information before associates would open the relevant cases.
The report identified inconsistent practices.
It also noted that several stores had created informal criteria that were not included in the official customer-service manual.
One location required customers to demonstrate “serious purchase intent.”
Another encouraged associates to prioritize customers who appeared “financially established.”
A third used the phrase “high-probability client.”
The phrases were vague.
The report did not establish how employees interpreted them.
But it showed that the language had entered internal communications.
Alicia opened the Beverly Hills section.
The boutique had one of the highest revenue figures in the company.
It also had one of the lowest first-time visitor presentation rates.
Alicia frowned.
The store had recorded 1,142 visits from customers who were not already in its client database.
Of those, 186 received presentations of merchandise valued above $25,000.
That was approximately sixteen percent.
The company average was thirty-one percent.
Alicia read the figures again.
She opened the next page.
The percentage became even more striking when the data was separated by customer category.
Customers who arrived through existing client referrals received presentations at a rate of forty-eight percent.
Customers who arrived without appointments received presentations at a rate of eleven percent.
That difference alone could have had legitimate explanations.
But the complaint records suggested something else.
Three complaints had been closed with nearly identical language.
Customer expectations did not align with the boutique's luxury-service standards.
Alicia highlighted the phrase.
The first complaint had been submitted by a woman named Denise Harper.
The second came from a man named Robert Ellis.
The third was filed by a customer whose name had been partially redacted in the report.
Alicia opened the original notes.
Denise Harper had visited the boutique to purchase a bracelet for her daughter's graduation.
She had asked to see a diamond piece priced at approximately $32,000.
According to the complaint, an associate had told her that the bracelet was not available for general viewing.
When Harper asked whether she could schedule a consultation, the associate allegedly responded that private appointments were reserved for established clients.
Harper had then purchased a similar bracelet from another jeweler.
The complaint had been closed two days later.
No follow-up call was recorded.
Robert Ellis's complaint was different.
He had entered the store with his wife and asked to see a limited-edition watch.
The associate reportedly asked whether he had an appointment.
He said he did not.
The associate then directed him toward the standard watch collection.
Ellis asked to see the limited edition.
The associate declined.
His complaint stated:
I have purchased from luxury stores for decades. I understand that certain pieces require additional handling. What I do not understand is why I was treated as though asking to see an advertised product was inappropriate.
The store's response was brief.
The customer was offered alternative merchandise consistent with his stated interests.
No explanation was provided for why the requested watch had not been shown.
The third complaint involved a woman who said security had followed her from the entrance to the diamond display.
The store had classified it as a security concern rather than a service complaint.