Alicia had never liked offices designed to impress visitors.
She preferred rooms where people could concentrate.
Marcus Reed was already seated.
He had brought a laptop, two folders, and a cup of coffee.
Naomi Ellis, the company's general counsel, entered shortly afterward.
She carried a thin legal pad and a tablet.
"Good morning," she said.
"Good morning."
Marcus looked at Alicia.
"I pulled the initial records from the customer-service database."
"All locations?"
"All twenty-three. Eighteen months of complaints, manager responses, and closure records."
Alicia sat down.
"How many?"
"Three thousand four hundred and twelve formal complaints."
She looked at him.
"That's more than I expected."
"Most are ordinary service issues. Delayed repairs, appointment scheduling, shipping problems, incorrect engraving, and warranty disputes."
"And the category we're concerned about?"
Marcus opened the first folder.
"We identified two hundred and fourteen complaints involving customers who reported being ignored, redirected, questioned about purchasing ability, or discouraged from viewing specific merchandise."
Alicia remained still.
"How many locations?"
"Eleven."
"How many in Beverly Hills?"
"Thirty-seven formal complaints over eighteen months."
Alicia looked toward Naomi.
"How many were closed without customer follow-up?"
Naomi checked her notes.
"Twenty-one."
Alicia looked at Marcus.
"Why?"
"Several were marked as resolved through an internal manager response."
"Was the customer contacted?"
"In some cases, we don't have evidence."
"How many?"
"Fourteen."
Alicia leaned back slightly.
"So twenty-one complaints were marked resolved, and fourteen have no documented customer contact."
"Correct."
"Who closed them?"
Marcus looked at the screen.
"Most were closed by Vanessa Whitfield or the assistant manager."
"How many by Vanessa?"
"Sixteen."
Alicia looked down at the table.
She had expected problems.
She had not expected so many complaints to disappear into a system that was supposed to preserve them.
Naomi spoke.
"Before we proceed, I want to make one distinction."
Alicia looked at her.
"We have complaints. We do not yet have verified findings. We need to preserve the original records, interview employees separately, and establish what happened in each case."
"Agreed."
"We also need to protect employee privacy. We shouldn't circulate customer names or personal details beyond the people who need them."
"Agreed."
Marcus nodded.
"I've already restricted access to the relevant records. No one at the store has been notified."
Alicia looked at him.
"Good."
Naomi opened her tablet.
"I prepared a preservation notice covering the customer-service system, appointment logs, point-of-sale records, employee schedules, training acknowledgments, internal messaging, and any communication concerning customer treatment."
"Send it to the appropriate records custodians."
"Already done."
"Has the regional office received it?"
"No."
"Keep it that way until we have a clear plan."
Naomi nodded.
Marcus turned his laptop toward Alicia.
"I also compared the complaint data with store performance reports."
Alicia studied the screen.
There were several columns.
Customer complaints.
Customer follow-up.
Private appointment conversion.
Average transaction value.
Repeat purchase rate.
The Beverly Hills location had strong revenue.
Its average transaction value was among the highest in the western region.
Its repeat-purchase rate was also strong.
But there was an unusual pattern.
Customers who submitted formal complaints were less likely to return.
That was not surprising by itself.
The concerning detail was that many complaints were followed by no documented attempt to contact the customer.
Alicia pointed toward the screen.
"Why does this show a zero under follow-up for so many cases?"
Marcus answered.
"Because the manager's closure note was treated as sufficient."
"Who approved that process?"
"The previous regional operations director."
"Was that an official company policy?"
"Not exactly. It appears to have developed as a local practice."
Naomi looked up.
"That's something we need to examine carefully. If employees were trained to use a certain process, we need to know who authorized it."
Alicia nodded.
"Find out."
Marcus moved to another page.
"I also reviewed the customer comments themselves."
He opened a document.
The first complaint was dated eleven months earlier.
I entered the Beverly Hills store to look at a diamond necklace. The employee at the door asked whether I was waiting for someone. I said I wanted to browse. She pointed toward the fashion jewelry display and told me the fine jewelry section was reserved for appointments. I later watched another customer walk directly to the same display and receive immediate assistance.
The second complaint was shorter.
I asked to see a bracelet listed online. The sales associate asked whether I had purchased from the store before. When I said no, she suggested I look at lower-priced items.
The third described a customer who had been asked to wait while two later arrivals were served.
Alicia read several more.
The language varied.
The experiences were different.
But the recurring theme was unmistakable.