Eli went back to Dry Creek on a Saturday, because a man cannot live on flour alone, and because the nails were still needed, and because, if Brandt's boycott was to be faced, it was better faced in daylight, in front of the town, than avoided in the hope that it would go away. Avoidance, Eli had learned, was a kind of agreement. He had avoided Dry Creek for three years, and the town had filled the silence with stories about him — soldier, killer, fugitive — and he did not want the town to fill this silence with a story about a man who had been beaten by a closed door.
He rode in early, before the heat, and he tied the bay horse at the rail, and he walked into the store, and the clerk looked up, and looked past him, and Brandt was there, as Eli had expected, standing near the counter, talking loudly, the way a man talks loudly when he wants a room to hear him, about water, and about strangers, and about a ranch twenty miles out where a man was harbouring people who did not belong, and about the sheriff, who would, Brandt was sure, see sense, once he understood the danger.
The store went quiet when Eli came in. It was not a large store, and there were perhaps a dozen people in it — farmers, a woman buying cloth, Tom Okafor at the far end, looking at a box of nails as if the nails were the most interesting thing in the world — and they all stopped, and they all looked, and Eli felt the weight of their looking, and he did not hurry, and he did not raise his voice, and he walked to the counter, and he said, to the clerk, in the same calm tone he used at the well, "Flour, please. And nails, if you have them for cash."
The clerk hesitated. His hand hovered over the counter. His eyes went to Brandt, and Brandt, smiling, said, in a voice that carried, "No credit for Carter. Cash only, and no nails. A man who gives our water to strangers does not need nails from this town."
Eli did not turn. He kept his eyes on the clerk, and he said, "I have cash. I am asking for flour and nails, for cash, in a public store, in daylight."
Brandt laughed, a short, sharp sound, and stepped closer, and said, "You heard me, boy," and then, catching himself, "Mr. Carter. You have made your choice. You chose strangers over your neighbours. Now your neighbours choose not to sell to you. That is how a town works."
It is how a town works, Eli said, and his voice was low, and steady, and it carried, because a low voice, in a quiet room, carries farther than a loud one. "When a town works that way. But this town also has a sheriff, and a deed office, and a creek, and I have something to say about that creek, and I will say it here, in public, so that no one has to take my word for it alone."
Tom Okafor, at the far end of the store, set down the box of nails, very quietly, and took a step toward Eli, and stood beside him, not touching him, not speaking, but standing, and Eli felt the weight of that standing, and was grateful for it, and did not show his gratitude, because showing it would have made Tom a target, and Tom was already a target enough.
I found a ditch, Eli said, and he said it to the room, not to Brandt, because the room was the jury that mattered, and Brandt was only one man in it. "On Dry Creek, above my ranch. Newly dug. It carries what water is left in the creek away from its course, east, to a herd. Kito found it. He measured it with me, in daylight, pace by pace, and he will tell you what he saw, because he saw it first, and because his eyes are good, and because he does not lie."
Kito was standing in the doorway. Eli had not seen him come in, and he did not know how long Kito had been there, but Kito stepped forward, into the light of the store, and stood beside Eli, on the other side from Tom, and the three of them stood together, in a row, in front of the counter, and the room looked at them, and Brandt looked at them, and Brandt's smile, for the first time, faltered.
I found the ditch, Kito said, in fluent, unhurried English, and his voice did not shake, and he did not look at Brandt, but at the room, at the farmers and the woman with the cloth, at the clerk, at the people who would carry the story home. "The earth was soft. The water was moving. It went to Mr. Brandt's herd. I measured it. I can show anyone who wants to see."
Brandt's face went red, and he said, loudly, "Lies. The boy is lying. He is a —" and he stopped, because Sheriff Ben Holloway was standing in the doorway, and the sheriff had come in quietly, the way a sheriff comes in when he wants to hear what a room is saying before the room knows he is there, and Holloway looked at Brandt, and at Eli, and at Kito, and at Tom, and he said, in his slow, deliberate voice, "Mr. Brandt. I will look at the ditch. Myself. In daylight. Tomorrow. And if there is a ditch, and if it carries creek water to your herd, we will talk about it then, in daylight, where everyone can see."