A Cowboy Gave Water to 3 Apache Strangers—The Next Morning, 25 Apache Women Arrived

Chapter 34

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The forged claim arrived in town on a Thursday, carried by Brandt himself, folded carefully, as if the folding made it true. He showed it in the store, to the storekeeper and to anyone who would listen, and he said that Eli Carter's deed was not clear, that the land had once been promised to Brandt's father, that the well had always been Brandt's by right, and that the paper proved it. The paper was old-looking, yellowed at the edges, with a signature that, at a glance, might have been Eli's, or might have been anyone's, and with dates that did not quite line up, if a person looked closely, which most people, in a store on a Thursday, did not.

Brandt's hired hands were gone by then. One had left for the rail line, the other for a ranch farther south, and Brandt stood alone in the store, holding his paper, and talking louder than was necessary, and the town listened, because a man talking loudly in a store is hard to ignore, and because Brandt had been a loud man in Dry Creek for a long time. But the town also remembered the ditch, and the sheriff's order, and the water, and the garden, and the women drawing water in turns, and so the listening was careful, and not quite believing, and Tom Okafor, who was in the store buying coffee, said, "Silas, show it to the sheriff. If it is true, he will know. If it is not, he will know that, too."

The store went very quiet when Brandt unfolded the paper, and the storekeeper, a thin man with ink on his fingers, leaned over the counter to look, and said, "Silas, that looks old." And Brandt said, "It is old. That is the point. It is older than Carter's claim." And Tom Okafor, who had come in for coffee and had stayed to listen, said, "Old paper can be made to look older, Silas. Show it to the sheriff, as I said. If it is true, he will know." And Brandt, who had hoped for a crowd, found instead a room full of people who were watching him carefully, and who were not quite believing, and he folded the paper again, and said he would show it to the sheriff, and that the sheriff would see, and he walked out, and the store, after a moment, went back to its business, but the talk went with him, down the street, and into the forge, and into the doctor's office, and it reached Holloway before Brandt did.

Holloway came, and Dr. Whitfield came, because she had been in town that day, and they examined the paper together, in the sheriff's office, in daylight, with Brandt watching, and Eli watching, and Kito watching, because Kito had ridden in with Eli and would not be left outside. Holloway read the paper slowly, and then he read it again, and then he sent for the county record, which was kept in a bound book in the office, in a careful hand, and he compared the dates, and the names, and the description of the land, and Dr. Whitfield, who had a steady eye for detail, pointed to the date on Brandt's paper, and to the date in the record, and said, quietly, "These do not agree. The record says Eli Carter bought this land three years ago, from the county, for cash, with a clear title. Your paper says the land was promised before that, but the promise is dated after the sale. A promise cannot come after the thing it promises."

Holloway nodded, and looked at Brandt, and said, in his slow way, "Silas, this paper is not true. The dates give it away. The record is clear. Eli's deed is clear. You will not bring another paper like this into my office." Brandt's face went red, and then pale, and he said that the record was wrong, and that the county was wrong, and that everyone was against him, and Holloway said, "No one is against you, Silas. The record is against you. There is a difference." And Brandt, alone now, without hired hands, without the town, without the paper, took the forged claim and folded it again, and put it in his pocket, and walked out of the office, and out of the store, and out of Dry Creek, for the season, to a ranch his cousin kept farther north, without a scene, because there was no scene left to make, and because the evidence, shown in daylight, had done what threats never could.

Eli rode home that evening with Kito, and the road was long and dusty, and the sun was low, and Kito said, "He will come back." And Eli said, "Maybe. Men like Brandt come back. But the deed will still be clear. And the well will still be ours. And the record will still say what it says." And Kito nodded, and said, "And the ditch?" And Eli said, "The ditch is filled in. Holloway saw to that." And they rode on, and the ranch came into sight, and the barn roof stood straight, and the garden stood green, and the women were drawing water in turns, and Sina was waiting in the yard, and Eli thought that a forged paper, like a diverted ditch, is a thing that looks strong until daylight falls on it, and then it is only paper, and only a ditch, and the truth, which is slower, holds.

News in the same category

A Cowboy Gave Water to 3 Apache Strangers—The Next Morning, 25 Apache Women Arrived

45 Part