A Cowboy Gave Water to 3 Apache Strangers—The Next Morning, 25 Apache Women Arrived

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Brandt opened his mouth, and closed it, and the room, which had been holding its breath, let it out, slowly, and the clerk, very quietly, put a sack of flour on the counter, and a box of nails beside it, and Eli paid, in cash, and thanked him, and picked up the parcels, and walked out, with Tom on one side and Kito on the other, and the sheriff behind them, and the town, watching from windows and doorways, watched them go, and the story of that morning, Eli knew, would travel faster than any rumour Brandt had ever spread, because it was true, and because it had been told in public, and because three men had stood together, and a sheriff had promised to look.

The woman with the cloth had stopped pretending to shop. She stood with her parcel clutched to her chest, watching, and the farmers by the seed bins had turned, one by one, and the clerk's hand, which had hovered over the counter, came slowly down to rest on the wood, as if he, too, wanted it known that he had heard. Brandt's hired hands, who had followed him in, stood just inside the door, their hats in their hands, saying nothing, and Eli saw, in the way they avoided Brandt's eye, that they were not his men in this. They were men paid by the day, and the day's pay did not stretch to lying for a ditch.

Eli felt the room change, the way a room changes when a story that has been whispered in corners is finally spoken aloud where everyone can hear it. It was not triumph he felt. It was relief, plain and tired, the relief of a man who has carried a measured fact for days, in paces and finger-widths, and has at last set it down on a counter in daylight, where the town can look at it. He thought of Sina, shelling beans on his porch, of Luz riding twenty miles in the dark for a doctor, of Kito walking a creek bed in the heat because a scout's job was to know the land, and he knew that whatever happened next, in the store or at the ditch, the truth had been spoken by the people who had lived it, and no closed door could unsay it.

Eli picked up the flour and the nails, and the weight of them in his arms felt like more than flour and nails. It felt like a town, deciding, one sack at a time, which way it would face, and whose word it would trust when the dust settled.

The sheriff came the next morning, in daylight, as he had promised, and he came the way a sheriff should come to look at evidence: alone, unhurried, with his horse walking, not running, and with no crowd behind him, because a crowd, Holloway knew, made a man defensive, and a defensive man did not see clearly.

Eli was waiting at the creek bed, with Kito beside him, and Brandt was already there, because Brandt had ridden out early, and was standing by the ditch, with his arms crossed, and his face set, and his two hired hands a little way off, by the horses, watching, and saying nothing, because hired hands, in a moment like this, know better than to speak.

Morning, Holloway said, and he dismounted, and he tied his horse, and he walked to the edge of the ditch, and he looked down, and he did not speak for a long time. He looked at the pool, at the water moving in the ditch, at the spoil heap, at the line of the ditch running east, toward the rise behind which Brandt's herd watered, and he looked at the fresh shovel marks, and at the earth, still dark and soft at the edges, and he looked at Kito, and at Eli, and at Brandt, and he said, "Show me."

Kito showed him. He walked the length of the ditch, pace by pace, the way he had walked it with Eli, and he pointed out the beginning, where the water left the creek, and the middle, where it crossed the old fence line, and the end, where it disappeared behind the rise, and he showed the sheriff the measurements, in paces and finger-widths, and the leaf, which he had left, weighted with a stone, at the place where the water moved fastest, and Holloway watched the leaf move, slowly, east, and he nodded, and he walked the ditch himself, and he knelt, and he put his hand in the water, as Eli had, and he felt it move against his palm, and he stood, and he wiped his hand on his trousers, and he looked at Brandt.

Mr. Brandt, Holloway said, and his voice was slow, and fair, and entirely without anger, which made it harder to argue with than anger would have been. "This is your ditch. The digging is fresh. The water is creek water. It goes to your herd. You have diverted the creek, in a drought, while your neighbours downstream go short. That is not your right. The creek is not yours to move."

Brandt's face went a deeper red, and he said, "The creek runs through my land downstream, Sheriff. I have a right to water my herd. Carter has a well. He does not need the creek. Those people at his ranch do not need —"

They need water, Holloway said, cutting him off, not loudly, but firmly, the way a man cuts off a sentence that has gone on too long. "Everyone needs water. That is the point of water. And Eli Carter's well is Eli Carter's, by deed, which I have read, and the sharing of it is Eli Carter's business, which I have already ruled on. Your ditch is not your business. It is a diversion, and it is unlawful, and you will restore it."

News in the same category

A Cowboy Gave Water to 3 Apache Strangers—The Next Morning, 25 Apache Women Arrived

45 Part