Eli had not known, when he married her, that he would bury her. No man knows that, and if he did, he would not marry, and the world would be emptier. Martha had been twenty-six, with dark hair and a laugh that came easily, and hands that were never idle, and a way of talking to the garden as if the plants could hear her. She had come east with him when he was young and restless and certain that a new place would make a new life, and she had made a home out of a rented house with a leaking roof, and she had made it a home so completely that Eli had forgotten, for a time, that a house could be anything else.
Rose had been born in the spring, small and loud, with Martha's dark hair and Eli's chin, and for three years the house had been full of her noise, her questions, her small wooden horse that Eli had carved for her from a piece of pine, with a mane made of twine and a tail made of the same, and legs that were not quite even, so that the horse rocked when it was pushed. Rose had carried it everywhere, to the table, to the garden, to bed, and she had named it, in the way children name things, after no one and for no reason, and the name had been Star, and Eli had never forgotten it.
The fever had come in December, with the cold. It had swept through the valley the way a fire sweeps through dry grass, house to house, and it had taken the old first, and the very young, and then it had taken Martha, who had nursed her neighbours before she nursed herself, and who had gone to bed with a headache and a chill and had not risen again. Eli had sat with her for three days, bringing water, bringing broth, holding her hand, watching her face grow pale and her breathing grow shallow, and he had prayed, though he was not a praying man, and he had bargained, though he had nothing to bargain with, and on the fourth morning she had died, quietly, in the gray light before dawn, with Eli holding her hand and Rose asleep in the next room.
Rose had survived only two days longer. She had taken ill on the day they buried Martha, and Eli had carried her to the doctor, and the doctor had shaken his head, and Eli had carried her home, and he had sat with her, and he had told her stories, and he had held her small wooden horse where she could see it, and on the second evening she had died, too, with the horse in her hand, and Eli had buried her beside her mother, beneath a cottonwood tree on the edge of the valley, where the ground was soft and the shade was kind in summer.
He had buried them both, and he had stood at the graves, and he had said nothing, because there was nothing to say that would make the ground any softer or the sky any kinder, and then he had gone back to the house, and he had sold almost everything he owned, the furniture, the tools, the wagon, the good horse, keeping only what would fit on the bay horse and in a single pack, and he had ridden west.
He had not come to the frontier looking for adventure. He had come because he needed somewhere his memories would have fewer places to follow him. In the valley, every road had been a road he had walked with Martha. Every market stall had been a place where Rose had pointed and asked. Every winter had been the winter. West, he thought, the land would be new, and the sky would be wide, and the memories would have to travel farther to find him, and on some days they would not find him at all.
The land had been cheap because nobody wanted it. The well was deep. The soil was stubborn. The nearest neighbours were miles away. Perfect. Or so he had thought, when he first rode onto it, three years earlier, and saw the sagging house and the leaning fences and the dry creek, and thought that a place no one wanted was a place where a man could be left alone with his grief and his work, and where the grief would, in time, grow quiet.
It had not grown quiet. It had grown familiar, which is a different thing. Eli had learned to live with it the way a man learns to live with a limp, by changing the way he walked, and by not expecting the limp to go away. He visited the graves every morning, in silence. There were no graves here, on this ranch, but there was a cottonwood tree, a different cottonwood, by the dry creek, and Eli had planted a small stone beneath it, and he went there each morning before sunrise, and he stood, and he said nothing, and he thought of Martha and Rose, and then he went to the cattle, and the well, and the fence line, and the work carried him through the day.
He kept Martha's wedding ring on a nail by the door. It was a plain gold band, worn thin, and it hung on the nail where he could see it when he came in and when he went out, and he never touched it except to take it down once a year, on the anniversary of the winter, and hold it in his hand, and put it back. He kept Rose's small wooden horse on the mantel, where the light from the window fell on it in the morning, and the twine mane was dusty, and one leg was loose, and Eli had never repaired it, because repairing it would have meant admitting that it was broken, and he was not ready to admit that, even after three years.