Silas read it twice, and then he folded it, once, twice, the way he had folded his list on the morning he rode to town, and he walked into the house, and he went to the hearth, where Rosa kept a small fire going even in spring, for coffee and for warmth in the mornings, and he held the letter over the flames, and he let it catch, and he watched it burn, the wax melting, the polite words curling and blackening and turning to ash, and he did not look at Eddie, and he did not look at Kaya, and he did not speak until the letter was gone.
Tell Mr. Cross, he said to the boy, who was still waiting in the yard, wide-eyed, "that there is no answer. Tell him Silas Wren does not sell free people, and does not buy them back, and does not answer letters that call a woman property. Tell him the gate will be barred, and the house will be watched, and if he wants to talk, he can come himself, in daylight, without Hale's men on the ridge."
The boy nodded, and rode away, fast, and Silas turned to Eddie, and his voice was quiet, and it was the quiet of a man who had made a decision and would not unmake it.
Keep the gate barred, he said. "Keep the rifle clean. Keep your eyes on the ridges. We are not looking for trouble, Eddie, but trouble is looking for us, and when it comes, I want us ready, and I want us together, and I want us to remember that we did the right thing, even if the right thing turns out to be hard."
Eddie nodded, and Rosa crossed herself, and Kaya, standing on the porch, looked at Silas, and her back was straight, and her eyes were steady, and Silas knew, without her saying a word, that she had heard the letter, and had understood it, and had decided, again, to stay.
That night the riders came back, closer this time, and Silas heard them before he saw them, the sound of hooves on the hard ground beyond the fence, slow and deliberate, not hurried, not hidden, the sound of men who wanted to be heard. He stood up from the porch, rifle in his hands, and Eddie came out of the barn with his own rifle, and Rosa stood in the kitchen doorway with a lamp, and Kaya stood in the doorway of Eddie's room, with the rifle Silas had given her held steady and low, the way he had shown her, and for a long moment nobody moved, and nobody spoke, and the only sound was the wind and the horses shifting in the dark.
Then the riders turned, two shadows against the stars, and rode away down the road toward town, and Silas let out a breath he had not known he was holding, and Eddie lowered his rifle, and Rosa crossed herself and went back inside to pray, in Spanish, for the house and for everyone in it, and Kaya stood in her doorway a moment longer, looking out at the dark, and then she went back inside, and locked her door from the inside, and Silas sat back down on the porch, and stayed awake until dawn, because sleep, that night, felt like a luxury he could not afford.
In the morning Kaya found him there, stiff and cold, and she brought him coffee without being asked, black and strong, the way Rosa made it, and she sat beside him on the porch steps, and she said, "They will come again, Silas. Next time they will not only ride past. Next time they will test the gate, and the fences, and whether we are watching." Silas nodded, and he drank the coffee, and he said, "Then we will be watching. And we will be ready. And we will not give them what they want, which is for us to be afraid in the dark, and careless in the daylight." He went inside then, and washed his face, and saddled Biscuit, because there was a sheriff in Red Hollow who held a lying paper, and a man who believed a paper was a lie had a duty to say so, even if the saying of it did no good at all.
Silas rode to town the next morning, alone, leaving Eddie at the ranch with the gate barred and Rosa with the kitchen door locked and Kaya with a rifle of her own, because he would not leave her unprotected, and he would not leave her as a prisoner, and a rifle, given freely, was a different thing from a rope, tied tight.
He rode the nine miles in the cool of the morning, Biscuit steady under him, the road empty, the hills dry and blue on either side, and he thought about what he was going to say to Sheriff Amos Reed, and about how little good it was likely to do, and about why he was going anyway. He was going because a man who believes a paper is a lie has a duty to say so to the man who holds the paper, even if the man who holds the paper does not want to hear it. He was going because Clara had taught him that silence, kept too long, becomes agreement, and he had been silent for three years, and he was done being silent.