Cole spoke once more, briefly, to confirm the dates on the patrol's list, and to say that he had seen the deserters himself, two of them, drinking in a camp south of Salt Wash, spending coin too freely for men who had deserted with nothing. Ellis read back the words he had written, and Kaya listened, and corrected one small thing, the day of the week, and Ellis changed it, and thanked her, and Greer nodded, as if the correction itself were proof that the testimony was true, because a liar does not correct a clerk over a day of the week.
The silence that followed was long and complete, and even the pen had stopped moving, and outside, on the street, a wagon passed, and a dog barked once, and then there was silence again, and Silas knew, with a certainty he had not felt in years, that the truth, spoken plainly, was stronger than any paper Slade could forge.
Slade spoke first, because Greer had given him his turn, and because a man like Slade cannot bear to be silent while other men speak the truth about him. He denied everything, and he denied it loudly, and he denied it with the practiced ease of a man who has denied things many times before and has learned that a loud denial, said often enough, can sound like a defense.
I bought her fair and legal, Slade said. "I have a paper. The patrol sold her to me. The captain signed it. I paid good money. I have the right to sell what I bought, and I have the right to keep what I bought, and this rancher stole my property when he cut her ropes and rode away with her."
His voice rose, and his face reddened, and his hands moved as he spoke, chopping at the air, and Greer watched him without expression, and Ellis wrote, and Kaya sat still, her hands folded, her eyes on Slade's face, and she did not look away.
Cross spoke next, and his voice was lower and harder, and he did not deny so much as threaten, in the careful language of a man who knows how to threaten without using the words that would hang him.
I have a claim on that water, Cross said. "I have had it for years. The spring in those hills is mine by right, and by use, and by the work my men have done there. Wren's ranch sits on land that was never his to keep, and the woman is only the beginning of what I will take back. I will not be questioned in this room by a private and a rancher and a woman who cannot read the papers she talks about."
Kaya did not flinch. She did not speak. She looked at Cross, and her look was steady, and Silas saw, in that look, the same steadiness he had seen on the platform, when she had stood with a rope on her wrists and had not begged, and had not cried, and had not looked away.
Greer waited until Cross had finished, and then he waited a moment longer, and then he turned to Ellis, the clerk, and said, "Mr. Ellis. The ledger."
Ellis stood, and his chair scraped on the floorboards, and he went to the shelf behind Greer's desk and took down a heavy, leather-bound book, and he carried it to the desk with both hands, as if it were heavier than it looked, and he opened it to a page marked with a strip of cloth, and he set it down in front of Greer.
This came from the fort this morning, Ellis said, and his voice was thin, but it carried. "By courier. The patrol's own ledger. The captain's own hand."
Greer read, and his eyes moved slowly down the page, and his face did not change, and then he looked up at Slade, and his look was cold and level, and Slade, for the first time that morning, stopped moving his hands.
There is no sale here, Greer said. "There is no signature here. There is no captive transferred to Obadiah Slade. There is a list of captives taken at Salt Wash, and there is a list of captives brought to the fort, and the numbers do not match the paper you have shown this town, Mr. Slade. Your paper is a forgery. Your sale was unlawful. Your claim is nothing."
He closed the ledger, and the sound of the cover shutting was loud in the small room, and he stood, and his height, which Silas had not noticed before, seemed suddenly to fill the office.
Obadiah Slade, Greer said, "you are charged with fraud and with the unlawful sale of a person. You will be held in this jail until the circuit judge hears your case. Jubal Cross, you will be held for questioning about the cutting of fences and the burning of a barn on the Wren ranch. Sheriff Reed, take them."
Amos Reed moved, and his hand was on Slade's arm, and Slade pulled away, and then Reed's other hand came up, and two deputies stepped in from the outer room, and Slade's protests rose and fell, and Cross cursed, low and hard, and then the door closed behind them, and the office was quiet again, and the morning light had moved a little further across the floorboards, and Kaya let out a breath she had been holding since she first sat down in the chair.
Silas looked at her, and she looked at him, and neither of them spoke, because there was nothing yet to say that would not sound too small for what had just happened. Cole stood by the window, his shoulders shaking once, and then still, and Greer sat down again, and he rubbed his eyes with one hand, and he looked at the ledger, and then at the three of them.