Red Hollow was quiet when he rode in, the square empty, the platform gone from the sun, the store awning rolled up, the church bell silent. It was a Tuesday again, and the town had gone back to being a town, and the auction was already becoming a story people told each other, and then a story they told themselves, until it sounded less shameful than it had been at noon.
Sheriff Amos Reed was in his office, by the jail with one cell, sitting at his desk with his boots up, reading a newspaper from Santa Fe that was already a week old. He was forty-eight, broad and grey, a man who had been sheriff for nine years because he was steady and because he did not make trouble, and because he understood that in a small town, a sheriff who made trouble did not stay sheriff for long.
Silas, Reed said, not looking up. "I heard you rode home with the woman. I heard Cross is angry, and Hale is angry, and half the town is talking. I was hoping you would stay out here and let it settle."
I came to ask you to look again at Slade's paper, Silas said, standing in the doorway, his hat in his hands. "Kaya says Slade bought her from deserters, not from the patrol. She says the paper is a lie. I believe her, Amos. I have looked her in the eye, and I believe her, and I am asking you, as a friend and as a neighbour, to look again."
Reed put the newspaper down, slowly, and he looked at Silas, and his face was tired, and it was the tired of a man who had already had this conversation in his head and had already decided how it would end.
Silas, he said, "the paper was good enough at noon. I looked at it, in front of the whole town, and I said it was good enough, and I am not going to stand up now, in front of Cross and Hale and half the valley, and say I was wrong. Do you understand what you are asking me to do?"
I am asking you to do what is right, Silas said.
I am asking you not to make trouble in Red Hollow, Reed said, and his voice was harder now, and his boots came down off the desk. "Cross has money, and Hale has men, and Slade has friends in Santa Fe, and you have a ranch nine miles out and a son nineteen years old and a housekeeper and a woman nobody in this town knows. Do not make trouble, Silas. Go home. Keep your head down. Let Cross forget about it, and let Hale forget about it, and let the town forget about it, and in a month nobody will remember her name."
Silas stood in the doorway for a long time, looking at the sheriff, looking at the jail cell behind him, empty and clean, looking at the paper on the desk, the newspaper from Santa Fe, the ink already fading in the sun, and he thought about Clara, and about Rosa, and about Eddie, and about Kaya, sitting on his porch that morning, telling him about Salt Wash in her own words, and he knew that he would not go home and keep his head down, and he knew that Reed knew it too.
I will not make trouble, Amos, Silas said, quietly. "But I will not give her back, and I will not pretend the paper is true when I know it is a lie. If Cross wants her, he will have to come and take her, and he will have to do it in daylight, and he will have to answer for it, to me, and to God, and to anyone else who is watching."
He put his hat back on, and he turned, and he walked out of the sheriff's office, and he rode home, nine miles, in the heat of the afternoon, and he did not look back at Red Hollow, because there was nothing behind him in Red Hollow that he needed, and everything ahead of him, on the road home, that he did.
The ride home was longer than the ride in, because the heat had settled over the road and Biscuit walked slow, and because Silas had time to think, and thinking, on a hot afternoon, is a heavy business. He thought about Reed, sitting behind his desk with his boots up, reading a newspaper a week old, a man who had been sheriff for nine years because he did not make trouble, and he thought about Cross, who made trouble for a living, and Hale, who paid for trouble to be made, and Slade, who sold trouble by the wagonload, and he thought about how small a ranch nine miles out of town could feel, when the whole valley seemed to be ranged against it.
But he thought, too, about Rosa, who had brought water and bread without being asked, and about Eddie, who had given up his room and offered his horse and his rifle, and about Kaya, who had told him the truth about Salt Wash in her own words, and who had asked for time and a horse and a place to stand, and he thought that a man could do worse, in a dry country, than to stand with people like that, behind a barred gate, with a rifle clean and a ledger honest.