He should have gone into the store. He knew it even as he stood there, with the sun on his hat and the noise of the crowd rising around him like water rising around a man's boots. He should have walked up the steps, set his list on the counter, bought his salt and his wire and his coffee and his lamp oil, and ridden home before the town could ask anything of him. That was the plan. That had always been the plan. Go in, buy what was written, ride home. Rosa would have the coffee by supper. Eddie would help him with the fence in the morning. The ranch would go on, quiet and orderly, the way it had gone on for three years, with no one asking Silas Wren to be anything but the silent rancher who kept to himself and did his work and came to town only when the larder forced his hand.
But his feet did not move toward the steps. His eyes moved, instead, toward the square, where something was happening that he did not yet understand, and where the crowd was thickest, and where two livery hands were dragging something heavy across the boards. He watched them for a long moment, his hand still on Biscuit's neck, feeling the horse's steady breathing under his palm, and he thought about Clara, and about Rosa waiting at the ranch, and about Eddie, who at nineteen had never yet seen the worst thing men could make a game of, and who would hear about this by sundown whether Silas stayed or not, and he felt the pull in his chest grow stronger, the pull that said turn around, and the other pull, quieter and harder to name, that said stay and see.
The sun beat down on the street, and the dust rose in small clouds where the boys ran, and the bell in the church tower hung silent, and Silas Wren stood in the shade by the rail, a man with a list in his pocket and a horse at his side, and he did not yet know that the town had other plans for the day.
He watched the men by the corral fence for a while longer, because there was nothing else to do with his eyes, and because looking at men was easier than looking at the square. One of them wore a coat too heavy for the heat, and sweat darkened the cloth under his arms, and he kept wiping his forehead with the back of his hand and then looking at his hand, as if surprised to find it wet. Another had a rifle slung across his back, the stock worn pale where his hand had rested on it for years, and he stood with his weight on one leg, his boot heel dug into the dust, his eyes moving over the crowd the way a man looked over cattle at a sale, counting, judging, deciding what was worth his money. A third man, younger, with a thin moustache and a bright red neckerchief, laughed too loudly at something the others said, and the laugh sounded forced, the way a laugh sounded when a man wanted to be thought easy in his mind and was not.
The women in the shade of the awning did not laugh. They stood with their arms folded, their shawls pulled close despite the heat, their faces set in the patient, watchful expression women wore when they were waiting for men to finish something foolish. One of them held a baby against her shoulder, patting its back in a slow, steady rhythm, and the baby slept through the noise, its small face turned toward her neck. Another woman, older, with gray hair pulled back tight under a bonnet, shook her head at something her neighbour said, and her lips pressed together in a thin line, and Silas thought she looked like a woman who had buried a husband and raised children and did not have time for entertainments that left a bad taste in the mouth.
Biscuit shifted his weight and stamped at a fly, and the sound of his hoof on the boards was loud in the pause between the voices from the corral. Silas ran his hand down the gelding's neck again, feeling the coarse hair and the warmth underneath, and he thought about the ride home, about the nine miles of open country and the quiet of the trail, and about how good it would feel to be out of the crowd and back where the only sound was the wind in the grass and the creak of the saddle. He thought about the beans without salt, too, and about how Rosa would look at him if he came home with nothing, and about how she would shake her head and say something in Spanish that he only half understood, and then say it again in English so he would understand it fully, and about how, for all that, she would still set a plate in front of him at supper, because that was what Rosa did.
He did not move. The pull in his chest was still there, strong as a rope, telling him to turn around, and the other pull, quieter, was still there too, telling him to stay, and he stood between them in the shade, with the sun white overhead and the street full around him, and he waited to see which pull would win.
Silas Wren, as I live.