A Wealthy Neighbor Screamed That a Black Man Hit Her — Then the Police Played Back 18 Seconds of Video

Chapter 10

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Mr. Greer did not move toward Mrs. Whitmore at any point during our presence. He kept his hands visible at his sides. He stated that he had not touched Mrs. Whitmore. He stated that he had been at least six feet away from her at all times."

She wrote down the handcuffs next, because that mattered and because she did not want anyone else to write it first.

"Officer Cole placed Mr. Greer in handcuffs for investigative detention at approximately 3:55 p.m. I directed Officer Cole to remove the handcuffs at approximately 3:57 p.m. after reviewing video evidence provided at the scene."

The video evidence. Brooks wrote that part slowly.

"Marisol Vega, 68, resident diagonally across the street, provided doorbell camera footage from her residence. The footage, wide angle, down the street, showed Mrs. Whitmore and Mr. Greer in the front yard area near the rose bed. The footage showed no physical contact between them. I rewound the footage eighteen seconds and played it a second time. The footage again showed no physical contact."

She quoted Evelyn exactly, because quotes were harder to argue with than summaries.

"Mrs. Whitmore stated, 'He hit me with his open right hand.' Mr. Greer stated, 'I did not touch her. I was six feet away.' Mrs. Whitmore later stated that Mr. Greer had filmed the incident on his phone. No such phone was observed in Mr. Greer's hands."

She added the phone video, because that was also evidence, even if it did not help the complaint.

"Mrs. Whitmore provided a video recorded on her own phone. The video began after the reported scream. It showed Mr. Greer standing still, more than six feet from Mrs. Whitmore. It showed no contact."

Brooks saved the draft and printed a copy to read on paper. She circled two times with a pen. 3:52. 3:57. Five minutes between arrival and the cuffs coming off. Five minutes that would be read very carefully by people who had not been there.

In the parking lot, Evan Cole sat in his cruiser with the engine off and replayed his body camera on the small dash monitor. He had watched it twice already. He watched it a third time.

He saw himself step out of the car, saw Evelyn Whitmore at the curb with her hand to her cheek, heard her voice, high and fast: "He hit me. He hit me right here, with his open hand."

He saw himself turn to Malcolm Greer. He saw Malcolm standing still, hands at his sides, his shirt still buttoned, his face closed and careful. He heard his own voice, younger than he liked, saying, "Sir, I'm going to need you to turn around."

He saw the cuffs go on. He saw Malcolm's wrists, dark against the steel, and the way Malcolm did not resist, did not even shift his weight. He saw Dana Brooks step into frame, calm, her hand raised, not touching anyone, saying, "Evan. Hold on. Let's look at the video first."

Cole stopped the playback. He sat in the dark car and put both hands on the steering wheel. He was twenty-seven years old and three years on patrol, and he had done what he thought the moment required. That was the problem. He had thought, and then he had acted, and Brooks had thought longer.

He got out of the car and went back inside. Brooks was still at her desk, reading the printed pages.

"Ma'am," he said.

She looked up.

"I watched it again," he said. "The bodycam."

"And?"

"I moved too fast," he said. "I heard her and I moved."

Brooks nodded once. She did not soften it and she did not sharpen it.

"You did," she said. "Write that in your supplement. Exactly that. Not an excuse. Just what happened, and when."

Cole went to his own desk and began to type.

At 7:20 p.m., Sergeant Angela Ruiz came in from the hallway with a paper cup of coffee and stood behind Brooks's chair. Ruiz was forty-four, eighteen years on the department, and she read standing up, the way she always did, one hand on the back of the chair.

She read the whole report without interrupting. When she finished, she set the coffee down and tapped the paragraph about the video.

"Is the footage preserved?" she asked.

"Marisol Vega has it on her doorbell system," Brooks said. "Cloud backup. She showed it to us on her phone."

"That is not preserved," Ruiz said. "That is available. Those are different things."

She picked up the phone on Brooks's desk and dialed dispatch.

"This is Sergeant Ruiz," she said. "I need the 911 recording for the Asheford Lane call this afternoon preserved tonight. Full audio, with the dispatcher timestamps. Flag it for Detective Bell, follow-up. Yes, tonight. Not Monday."

News in the same category

A Wealthy Neighbor Screamed That a Black Man Hit Her — Then the Police Played Back 18 Seconds of Video

45 Part