A Wealthy Neighbor Screamed That a Black Man Hit Her — Then the Police Played Back 18 Seconds of Video

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The afternoon was still and warm. The crepe myrtles stood motionless over the street. Somewhere across the road, a garden hose hissed and then stopped. Evelyn stood by her fence with the phone to her ear, tears on her cheeks, telling a stranger that she was afraid, and Malcolm stood on the public sidewalk, six feet away, and waited for the police to come. He thought about how quickly it had happened, how little time there had been between a question and a scream, and how completely the afternoon had changed. A minute earlier he had been a man walking home from helping a neighbor move a planter. Now he was a man standing on a sidewalk while a woman told the police he had attacked her, and there was nothing he could do to make the minute before come back.

Officers Evan Cole and Dana Brooks arrived in under four minutes.

Their cruiser turned onto Asheford Lane with its lights off but its engine audible, and it stopped at the curb a short distance from Evelyn's house. Both officers got out together. Both had their body cameras recording before they approached. Cole was twenty-seven, three years on patrol, broad-shouldered and quick in his movements. Brooks was thirty-four, nearly a decade on, and she spoke less than Cole did but watched more. She wrote unusually detailed reports, a fact Malcolm would learn later. In the moment, he noticed only that she was the one who looked at the ground, at the fence, at the distance between him and Evelyn, before she looked at either of their faces. She took in the roses, the bucket, the shears, the wet patch on his shirt collar, and the space between the two of them, and she filed all of it away without comment.

Evelyn saw the cruiser and her voice rose.

"Thank God," she said. "He's still here."

Cole moved toward Malcolm. Brooks moved toward Evelyn. The two officers separated without needing to discuss it, each taking the person they had been trained to take, and the space between them became the space where the story would be told, twice, in two different versions, to two different listeners.

"He came onto my property," Evelyn said, her words coming fast now. "I told him to leave. He became aggressive, called me names, and then hit me."

Malcolm did not move. He kept his hands at his sides, open, visible.

"Did you strike her?" Cole asked him.

"No," Malcolm said.

"Did you touch her?"

"No."

"Were you on her property?"

"No. I was on the sidewalk. I have been on the sidewalk the entire time."

Cole looked at him for a moment, then asked for his identification. Malcolm took his wallet from his back pocket slowly, keeping his movements deliberate, and handed over his driver's license. Cole read it.

"Eighteen Asheford Lane," Cole said.

"Yes," Malcolm said. "Less than two hundred yards from here. I've lived there fourteen months."

Brooks turned to Evelyn. "Ma'am, can I see your identification?"

Evelyn stared at her. "You know who I am."

"I don't," Brooks said.

"I've lived here nineteen years."

"That doesn't tell me your name, ma'am," Brooks said, her voice even. "I need to see identification."

Evelyn hesitated, then turned and walked toward her open garage, her steps stiff with indignation, and returned a moment later with her wallet. She held out her license without meeting Brooks's eyes. The garage was tidy and well lit, its shelves lined with labeled bins, and the wallet came from a handbag on a hook by the door. Brooks took the license, read it, wrote the name in her notebook, and handed it back without comment. She did not apologize for asking. She did not explain why she had asked. She simply recorded what she had been given, the way she recorded everything else.

Cole, meanwhile, had gestured Malcolm toward the cruiser.

"Stand by the cruiser for me," he said. "For everyone's safety, keep your hands visible."

Malcolm walked to the cruiser and stood beside it, his hands at his sides. The cruiser's hood was warm from the drive. He could hear the radio murmuring inside, a dispatcher's voice too low to make out. He kept his eyes forward, on the street and the houses, and he thought about how strange it was to be standing beside a police car on his own street, in the middle of the afternoon, with his neighbors watching from their windows.

"Officer," he said, "my hands have been visible since you arrived."

"I'm giving you an instruction," Cole said.

"And I'm following it," Malcolm said.

He said it without anger, and without the edge that Cole might have expected. He had been following instructions all afternoon, and all his life, in rooms where the rules were written down and in streets where they were not, and he knew the difference between an instruction and an accusation. This was an instruction. He would follow it.

News in the same category

A Wealthy Neighbor Screamed That a Black Man Hit Her — Then the Police Played Back 18 Seconds of Video

45 Part