The enforcement-review committee met for the first time on a Tuesday evening in the community room, at the long table under the fluorescent lights. Malcolm Greer sat at the far end with a folder in front of him, a pen in his hand, and a printed copy of the covenants open to the page he needed. Tom Okafor sat to his left. Grace Liu sat across from him with a notebook. Harold Finch, the HOA president, sat at the head of the table, and he looked older than he had a year before, and tired in a way that had nothing to do with sleep.
The first case was a fence. A neighbour on the far side of the subdivision, a man named Daniel Reeves, had built a six-foot fence along the side of his lot. The covenant allowed four feet in a side yard. A complaint had come in, with photographs, and the file had been passed to the committee because the old way of handling such things — a letter, a fine, a second letter, a larger fine — was the way that had nearly broken the neighbourhood.
Daniel Reeves sat in the chair at the end of the table, his hands flat on his knees. He was in his forties, a contractor, and he had built the fence himself over two weekends. He had brought his own copy of the covenants, folded and marked.
"Mr. Reeves," Harold Finch said, "the committee has your file. The complaint says the fence exceeds the height allowed in the side yard. Do you have anything to add before we discuss it?"
"I built it to keep my dog in," Reeves said. "She jumps a four-foot fence. I didn't check the section. That's on me. But I want to know what the rule is, exactly, and how long I have to fix it."
Malcolm opened his folder. "Section 7.3," he said. "Side-yard fences, four feet maximum, measured from grade. That's the section the complaint cites, and it's the right section."
Reeves nodded. "All right. Four feet."
"And the procedure," Malcolm said, "is a fourteen-day cure period. That's fourteen days from the date of the written notice, to bring the fence into compliance. No fine during the cure period. No fine at all if the fence is corrected within it."
Grace Liu looked up from her notebook. "And if it isn't corrected?"
"Then the committee meets again," Malcolm said, "and the fine is set out in writing, with the section cited, and a second cure period if the board agrees one is warranted. But the first step is the notice and the fourteen days. That's the procedure the board adopted, and it's the procedure we're going to follow."
Reeves let out a breath he had been holding. "Fourteen days," he said. "I can cut it down in a weekend. I can do it this Saturday."
"Then that's the plan," Harold said. He looked around the table. "Any objections?"
Nobody objected. Tom Okafor wrote the date on the notice form. Grace Liu read it back aloud, slowly, so Reeves could hear every word: the section, the height, the fourteen days, the date by which the work had to be done, and the name and number of the person to call when it was finished.
Reeves stood and shook Harold's hand, and then Malcolm's. "Thank you," he said. "I expected a fight."
"It isn't a fight," Malcolm said. "It's a rule, and a date, and a chance to fix it."
After Reeves left, the room was quiet for a moment. Harold looked at the folder in front of him, and then at Malcolm.
"You asked one question," Harold said. "The section. That was the whole meeting."
"It was the only question that mattered," Malcolm said.
Grace Liu closed her notebook. "He came in braced for a fine," she said. "He left with a date."
"That's the difference," Tom said. "Under the old way, he'd have had a letter by Friday and a fine by the end of the month, and he'd have spent the whole time angry at us instead of fixing his fence. Now he'll spend Saturday fixing his fence, and he'll be done with us by Monday."
Grace opened her notebook again and wrote a note in the margin. "We should use the same form every time," she said. "Section, notice date, cure date, who to call. Same words, same order. Then nobody has to guess what we meant."
Harold nodded. "Agreed. We'll make it the standard form."
They filed the notice in the committee's folder, and Harold signed it, and Malcolm put the folder in his bag. On the drive home, he thought about the fence, and the fourteen days, and the way a man's shoulders had come down when he heard a rule stated plainly instead of a punishment delivered in a letter. It was a small thing. It was also the thing he had agreed to serve on the committee to do. A cited section. A cure period. A question asked once, and answered.