An Apache Tribe Was Dying Of Thirst In The Desert — Until A Lone Cowboy Led Them To Secret Water

Chapter 39

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

 

Then the lawyer laid out the pumping log, the book Jesse Corbin had kept in his own hand for three years, and Corbin himself stepped forward and spoke, in a voice that shook at first and then steadied, the way Hank's hands had steadied on the morning of the blast. He told the court how the pump had been run at night, when no inspector was watching, and how the water had been sold to the stamp mill at a price the company never reported, and how Ashworth had ordered the log kept in two books — one for the inspectors, and one, the true one, that Corbin had hidden in his sister's house in the village. His sister stood in the circle with her baby on her hip, and she did not look away from her brother while he spoke, and Hank thought that was the bravest thing he had seen all summer, braver even than the blast, because Corbin was testifying against the man who paid his wages, in front of the man himself.

 

Then Sari laid the pottery map on the blanket, beside the photographs, and Nana Hina came forward and put her old hands on it, and she told the judge, through Sari translating, how her father had taken her down into the cistern when she was twelve years old, and how the cistern had watered the village through droughts before any white man had drawn a map of Arizona, and how the village had used that water, year after year, in the open, without hiding it, because it was theirs by use, not by paper. The judge listened, and his clerk wrote, and when Nana Hina was done, the judge asked her one question: "And the mine? When did the mine first take water from this ground?"

 

Nana Hina looked at Ashworth, and she said, in English, slowly and clearly, so that there would be no need for translation, "The mine took water when the captain blew up the mountain. Before that, the mountain gave water to us. After that, the mountain gave water to no one, until yesterday."

 

Dr. Ferreira spoke last, quietly, from her book of the sick: the names of the children with dysentery from muddy well water, the old man who had died in the sixth week of digging, the babies born too weak to cry in the third year of the drought. She did not raise her voice. She did not need to. A book of the sick, read aloud in a circle in the desert, is its own kind of evidence, and the judge wrote down every name.

 

Ashworth tried to speak, twice, and the judge held up his hand, twice, and then the judge stood, and the circle went silent, and he gave his ruling standing up, with the pump line behind him and the stone wall at his feet.

 

"The territory recognizes prior beneficial use," he said. "Use, open and continuous, before any permit, before any charter, is a right, and it does not vanish because the people who hold it do not write it in English. The village of Tasai used this water before the Saguaro Wells Copper Company existed, and the company will pump no more water from this aquifer until the village cistern is full, and the conduit is repaired, and this court is satisfied. The injunction against the village is dissolved. The injunction against the company begins now."

 

He turned to Ashworth then, and his voice changed, the way a man's voice changes when he is no longer weighing evidence but delivering a sentence. "And as to the other matters in the petition — the army contract fraud of 1884, the survey blast ordered under a false report, and the diversion of relief supplies — those are not water matters, and they are not mine to try here. They are matters for the federal marshal, who is riding behind me with a warrant. Mr. Ashworth, you will go with him. Mr. Ross, you will go with him as well, on the charge of embezzling relief supplies consigned to this village."

 

Ross went white, and Ashworth went very still, and for a moment Hank thought the captain would draw a weapon or give an order, the way captains do when their authority fails them. But Ashworth only looked at Hank, across the circle, and Hank looked back, and neither of them said anything, because there was nothing left to say between a captain and the man who had once carried out his orders and had finally learned to stop.

News in the same category

An Apache Tribe Was Dying Of Thirst In The Desert — Until A Lone Cowboy Led Them To Secret Water

45 Part