"Camille, I agree that the numbers deserve attention. But we should be careful about drawing conclusions before the review is complete. A complaint isn't automatically evidence of misconduct. Banks have complicated verification procedures. Sometimes customers misunderstand why a process is necessary."
Camille looked at him.
"That is true."
David seemed relieved.
Then she continued.
"And sometimes employees use legitimate procedures as an excuse to treat people differently. That's why we investigate the facts rather than assume either explanation."
The relief disappeared from his face.
Eleanor Price sat at Camille's right. She had served as board chair for six years and had watched several executives mistake confidence for competence. She knew Camille well enough to recognize that her calmness was not an invitation to negotiate away the seriousness of a problem.
Thomas Bennett, general counsel, opened a document on his tablet.
"We've issued a preservation instruction to the Wabash branch, the regional office, and the relevant departments at headquarters. That includes customer records, internal messages, branch telephone logs, appointment records, surveillance footage, complaint notes, and personnel communications."
"Good," Camille said. "Has anyone confirmed whether the surveillance footage from this morning has been secured?"
"Not yet. The branch system is managed through regional operations. We're requesting a direct copy from the vendor."
"Requesting isn't securing."
Thomas nodded.
"I'll have the vendor contacted directly."
"Do that. And make sure no one at the branch is given an opportunity to edit, overwrite, or selectively export the footage."
Margaret added a note.
Camille returned her attention to the screen.
"Let's start with the complaints. I want to know what happened to the people who submitted them."
Margaret changed the presentation.
The first complaint appeared.
CUSTOMER: UNKNOWN — WABASH BRANCH
DATE: MARCH 14, THREE YEARS EARLIER
SUMMARY: CUSTOMER REPORTED BEING ASKED TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL IDENTIFICATION AFTER PRESENTING A VALID GOVERNMENT-ISSUED PHOTO ID AND ACCOUNT CARD.
DISPOSITION: CLOSED — CUSTOMER EDUCATION PROVIDED.
Camille read the final line twice.
"Who provided the customer education?"
Margaret searched the record.
"Martin Keller."
"Was the customer interviewed?"
"No."
"Was the employee who requested additional identification interviewed?"
"No."
"Was there a record of what additional identification was requested?"
Margaret hesitated.
"No."
Camille looked toward David.
"Then what exactly was investigated?"
David shifted in his chair.
"The branch manager reviewed the complaint and provided a response."
"That's not an investigation."
"No," Margaret said quietly. "It isn't."
The second complaint appeared.
CUSTOMER: ELIZABETH HARRIS
DATE: JUNE 22, THREE YEARS EARLIER
SUMMARY: CUSTOMER REPORTED THAT HER APPOINTMENT WITH A PRIVATE BANKING REPRESENTATIVE WAS CANCELED AFTER SHE ARRIVED. SHE STATED THAT AN EMPLOYEE TOLD HER THE APPOINTMENT WAS PROBABLY A MISTAKE BECAUSE THE BRANCH DID NOT HANDLE ACCOUNTS LIKE HERS.
DISPOSITION: CLOSED — CUSTOMER DECLINED FURTHER CONTACT.
Camille leaned forward.
"Did she decline further contact before or after someone contacted her?"
Margaret opened the underlying record.
"There's an outbound call listed. Duration, thirty-eight seconds."
"Who called?"
"Martin Keller."
"Was the call recorded?"
"No."
"Are there notes?"
"One sentence. 'Customer advised that private banking eligibility requirements were explained.'"
"Did she actually receive an explanation?"
"We don't know."
Camille's gaze remained on the screen.
"Then we need to ask her."
David glanced toward Margaret.
"Can we identify her?"
"Yes. The complaint includes a customer number and an old telephone number. We can contact her through an independent investigator."
"Do that," Camille said.
The next record involved an elderly couple.
They had visited the Wabash branch to discuss a certificate of deposit. They reported being kept in the lobby for nearly an hour while other customers who arrived later were helped.
The branch response said the couple had been waiting because of an unusually busy morning.
The customer had included the names of two employees who were present.
Neither employee had been interviewed.
A later complaint involved a Latino business owner who said a banker had discouraged him from applying for a commercial credit line because, according to the complaint, "business lending might be too complicated for someone with a company of his size."
The file was marked:
CUSTOMER EXPECTATIONS NOT ALIGNED WITH AVAILABLE SERVICES.
Camille sat back.
"Who wrote that?"
Margaret checked.
"Andrew Mitchell."
The room became still.
Andrew was the regional operations director.
He had called Martin Keller that morning, ostensibly to warn him not to make any further mistakes. He had also been responsible for reviewing several of the complaints now displayed on the screen.
Eleanor turned toward Margaret.
"Was Andrew aware of the original allegations?"
"According to the records, yes."
"Then why was the complaint closed?"
Margaret did not answer immediately.
"I don't know yet."
Camille folded her hands.
"Let's find out."