Through the narrow glass panel, she could see Martin standing behind his desk, talking on the phone.
His expression was irritated.
He was gesturing with one hand.
He had no idea how many people had witnessed what happened.
Or perhaps he did.
And that was why he was so angry.
At 1:15, a woman named Elizabeth Harris answered a call from an independent investigator.
She was sixty-three years old and lived in a quiet neighborhood on the South Side. She had worked for thirty-one years as an elementary-school principal before retiring.
When the investigator introduced herself and explained that First National was reviewing an old complaint, Elizabeth initially refused to speak.
"I already told your bank what happened," she said. "Nobody cared."
The investigator did not argue.
"I understand why you might feel that way. I'm not calling to defend the bank. I'm calling because the review team wants to hear directly from you."
Elizabeth was quiet.
"Why now?"
"Because the complaint has been reopened."
"By whom?"
"I can provide the name of the executive overseeing the review if you'd like."
Elizabeth considered it.
"Go ahead."
"Dr. Camille Whitaker."
There was a pause.
Elizabeth had seen Camille's name in financial news. She knew the Whitaker Consortium had recently acquired a controlling interest in First National Financial Group.
But that was not what mattered to her.
"What does Dr. Whitaker want to know?"
"What happened when you visited the Wabash branch three years ago."
Elizabeth walked to the kitchen and sat down.
"I had an appointment," she began. "A real appointment. I had the confirmation email. I had the account information. I had spoken to the private banking representative the week before."
"Do you remember the representative's name?"
"Yes. Mr. Lawson. He was professional. He told me to bring certain documents."
She paused.
"When I arrived, the receptionist couldn't find the appointment."
"What happened next?"
"She asked me to wait. I waited twenty minutes. Then Mr. Keller came out of his office."
The investigator made a note.
"What did he say?"
"He looked at me and asked who I was there to see. I explained. He asked whether I had been referred."
Elizabeth's voice tightened.
"I told him I had an appointment. He said the branch did not normally schedule private banking consultations for customers with accounts like mine."
"Did he explain what he meant by accounts like yours?"
"No."
"Did you ask?"
"Of course I did."
Elizabeth laughed once, without humor.
"He looked at me as though I was making things difficult. Then he said the appointment was probably entered incorrectly."
The investigator asked what happened afterward.
Elizabeth described being told to sit down. She described watching two other customers arrive and receive assistance while she remained in the lobby. She described finally asking whether someone could contact Mr. Lawson.
"That's when Mr. Keller said I should consider another branch."
"Did you feel you were treated differently because of your race?"
Elizabeth did not answer immediately.
"Yes."
"Can you explain why?"
"Because I had the documents. I had the appointment. I had done everything I was asked to do. And he still treated me as if I had wandered into the wrong building."
She took a breath.
"I had spent thirty-one years being responsible for children. I had sat in meetings with district officials, parents, attorneys, and people who thought they knew more than I did. I was not afraid of asking questions. But that day, I felt humiliated."
"Did anyone from the bank follow up?"
"One phone call. Mr. Keller. He told me that the branch had explained the eligibility requirements."
"Did he ask whether you wanted to make another appointment?"
"No."
"Did he offer to connect you with the private banking representative?"
"No."
Elizabeth's voice softened.
"I didn't want special treatment. I wanted the appointment I had already made."
The investigator thanked her.
Before ending the call, Elizabeth asked one question.
"Is this really going to change anything?"
The investigator did not promise what she could not guarantee.
"I can't promise an outcome. But your account is being included in an independent review."
Elizabeth looked toward the window.
"Then please make sure someone actually reads it this time."
At 2:05, Margaret Shaw received the first evidence update.
The original complaint files contained more than the summaries suggested.
Several included attachments.
A customer had saved screenshots of an appointment confirmation. Another had provided a copy of a letter sent to the regional office. A third had supplied a written timeline of events.
None of those attachments appeared in the final complaint summaries.
Margaret called Camille.
"There's something you should see."