Removing the independent review requirement and making customer confirmation optional will weaken the reliability of the complaint database. The proposed changes may allow unresolved cases to appear as successfully closed.
Andrew's response was attached.
The changes are intended to reduce unnecessary administrative escalation. Branch managers remain responsible for professional customer service. We should avoid creating a system that assumes every disagreement requires a compliance investigation.
Camille read the email.
"Did anyone respond to the specific concern about unresolved cases appearing successfully closed?"
Michael shook his head.
"No."
"Did the changes proceed?"
"Yes."
"Did you raise the issue again?"
"Twice."
"What happened?"
"The first time, I was told the system was already approved. The second time, I was told I needed to support the operational direction of the company."
"Did you?"
Michael looked at her.
"No."
Michael explained that he had begun comparing the original complaint records with the new reports.
He noticed that certain cases were disappearing from the escalation summaries.
The complaints had not been deleted.
They had been reclassified.
Some were moved into ordinary service inquiries.
Others were marked as customer education matters.
A few were recorded as closed after brief telephone conversations, even when the customer had never confirmed a resolution.
He had raised concerns with his supervisor.
The response was to stop comparing the old and new systems.
Michael had refused.
Three months later, his responsibilities were reduced.
He was removed from the complaint analytics project and reassigned to general documentation.
A few months after that, he resigned.
"Did you believe you were being punished?" Patricia asked.
Michael nodded.
"I did."
"Did you report retaliation?"
"I submitted an internal complaint."
"Where is it?"
Michael opened another folder.
"I kept the confirmation."
The complaint had been received by human resources.
It had been referred to regional management.
Then it had been closed as an internal disagreement.
Camille looked at the record.
"Who approved the closure?"
Michael pointed to the name.
Andrew Mitchell.
The room became quiet.
Patricia looked at Michael.
"Why did you keep these documents?"
"Because I knew what they were doing was wrong."
"Why didn't you release them earlier?"
Michael gave a tired smile.
"I have a family. I had a mortgage. I didn't know whether anyone would believe me. And I didn't want to spend the rest of my life fighting a company that had more lawyers than I had savings."
Camille nodded.
"That is understandable."
Michael looked at her.
"I don't expect you to take my word for anything. I want you to verify every document."
"We will," Patricia said.
Michael closed the folder.
"There's something else."
Camille waited.
"The reporting changes weren't the only problem."
"What else?"
"Someone created a list."
"What kind of list?"
"A list of branches that were expected to improve their complaint performance before annual reviews."
Michael removed one final document.
The heading read:
REGIONAL CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE RECOVERY PLAN
Wabash was at the top.
Below it were six other branches.
Each had a target reduction in escalated complaints.
The document included monthly targets and performance deadlines.
Camille looked at the dates.
The plan had been created before several of the complaints she had been reviewing.
It suggested that management had been focused on reducing escalation numbers even as customer concerns continued to arrive.
"Who prepared this?" she asked.
Michael pointed to the signature.
Andrew Mitchell.
"Who approved it?"
The approval field contained the name of Richard Coleman, senior vice president of operations.
Camille placed the document on the table.
"Mr. Grant, thank you."
He nodded.
"I hope this helps."
"It does."
She paused.
"But we need to be careful. These documents will be verified independently. If you have any additional records, provide them directly to the investigation team."
"I will."
As Michael left the room, Patricia turned toward Camille.
"This changes the scope again."
Camille looked at the document.
"Yes."
"Andrew wasn't simply reviewing complaints. He was directing a system that rewarded lower escalation numbers."
"And someone above him approved it."
Patricia nodded.
"We need to interview Richard Coleman."
Camille stood.
"Then let's arrange it."
At 10:00, Richard Coleman received an interview request.
He was sixty-two years old and had served as senior vice president of operations for eleven years.
He was known inside the bank as a disciplined executive who disliked surprises.
He had a reputation for demanding efficiency.
He also had a close working relationship with David Reynolds.
When he read the interview notice, he immediately called David.
"What's happening?"
David answered.
"An investigation."
"I know that. Why am I being interviewed?"
"Your approval appears on a regional complaint reporting proposal."
Richard paused.
"That was an operational efficiency project."
"It is now part of the investigation."