"I may have been aware of isolated cases."
Patricia displayed the case involving Robert Jenkins.
The original letter described the treatment of an elderly couple.
The final summary contained only a short statement about customer expectations.
Andrew stared at the screen.
"Who removed the attachment?" he asked.
"We're asking you."
"I don't know."
"The record shows your account accessed the case."
Andrew shifted.
"I reviewed many cases."
"Did you read the letter?"
"I can't remember."
Patricia displayed the access log.
Andrew's account had opened the attachment on the same day the case was closed.
He looked at the screen for several seconds.
Then he said:
"I may have reviewed it."
"Why did you approve closure?"
"Because the branch manager reported that the matter had been addressed."
"Was the customer contacted?"
"I don't know."
"Was the complaint resolved?"
"I don't know."
Patricia waited.
"Then what was the basis for closing it?"
Andrew looked down.
"I relied on Martin's report."
Camille spoke through the video connection.
"Mr. Mitchell, you have repeatedly said that branch managers were expected to use judgment. What standards were they expected to follow?"
Andrew looked toward the screen.
"Customer service policies. Verification procedures. Branch operating guidelines."
"Which document explained how to determine whether a customer was appropriate for private banking?"
"There were general eligibility guidelines."
"Did those guidelines authorize managers to discourage customers from scheduling appointments based on appearance or assumptions about their finances?"
"No."
"Did they authorize managers to close complaints without contacting customers?"
"Not specifically."
"Did they authorize managers to classify complaints as resolved without evidence?"
Andrew hesitated.
"Not specifically."
Camille nodded.
"Then why did you allow the practice?"
Andrew leaned forward.
"Because the region was under pressure to improve performance."
"From whom?"
"Senior operations."
"Who?"
"Richard Coleman."
"Did David Reynolds personally instruct you to reduce complaint numbers?"
Andrew shook his head.
"Not directly."
"Did he know about the performance targets?"
"Yes."
"Did he know that complaints were being closed without confirmation?"
Andrew paused.
"I don't know what he knew."
Camille continued.
"Did you tell him?"
Andrew did not answer.
Patricia returned to the questions.
"Mr. Mitchell, did you ever instruct Martin Keller to discourage customers from applying for services?"
"No."
"Did you know he was doing so?"
"I knew there had been complaints."
"Did you investigate?"
"I reviewed the cases."
"Did you interview the customers?"
"No."
"Did you interview the employees who raised concerns?"
"No."
"Did you verify the eligibility decisions?"
"No."
"Then what did you review?"
Andrew looked at the table.
"Management summaries."
Patricia closed the folder.
The interview continued for another hour.
Andrew admitted that he had approved complaint closures based on branch manager summaries.
He acknowledged that he had not independently verified several complaints.
He also admitted that he had received employee concerns about Martin Keller but had not referred them to independent review.
When asked why, he gave the same answer several times.
He had trusted the branch manager.
He had believed the system was functioning.
He had been trying to keep the region efficient.
But by the end of the interview, those explanations had begun to sound less like reasons and more like excuses.
At 11:30, Andrew requested a private conversation with Thomas Bennett.
The investigators agreed to a short meeting with counsel present.
Andrew looked exhausted.
"I want to clarify something."
Thomas nodded.
"Go ahead."
"I did not create this system to discriminate against customers."
"That will be considered."
"I was trying to improve efficiency."
"That will also be considered."
Andrew rubbed his forehead.
"But the system got out of control."
Thomas said nothing.
Andrew looked toward the closed door.
"Martin was a difficult manager. He was good at keeping the branch running, but he had his own ideas about customers."
"Did you know that?"
"I knew he could be dismissive."
"Did you address it?"
"Not properly."
"Why?"
Andrew looked down.
"Because he produced results."
Thomas remained silent.
Andrew continued.
"He kept the numbers up. He retained customers. His branch was always near the top of the rankings."
"Even when complaints were being closed without investigation?"
Andrew nodded slowly.
"I suppose so."
Thomas asked:
"Did you ever consider that the numbers might be wrong?"
Andrew gave a bitter smile.
"Not until now."
At 1:00, the board received the final draft of the independent investigation report.
It was more than two hundred pages long.
The executive summary contained several key findings.
Finding One: Unequal Customer Treatment
The investigation found repeated instances in which customers were treated differently in access to banking services, appointment scheduling, verification procedures, and customer support.