The spring did not look like a place worth stealing, and that was the first thing Elias learned about it. It was not grand. It did not roar or foam or throw itself off a cliff in a white plume. It came out of the red rock low and quiet, a clear thread of water that gathered itself in a stone basin before it slipped away down the canyon in a creek no wider than a man's stride. Tall grass bowed over it. Cottonwoods threw a broken shade across the water in the heat of the day. In the evening, when the light turned the canyon walls the colour of old brick, the surface of the basin held the sky so cleanly that a man could have believed the sky itself had come down to drink.
Ren knew the spring the way a woman knows a room she has kept all her life. She knew where the water ran strongest after rain and where it sulked in a dry spell. She knew which stones to move when silt choked the outlet and which to leave alone, because the water had settled its own course and did not thank a meddler. She knew the birds that came at first light and the tracks that belonged to deer, to coyote, to a badger that lived under the far bank and minded its own business unless a man was foolish enough to reach into its hole. Elias, who had spent his youth learning to read ground for an army and for a surveyor's line, found that he had never really learned to read water until Ren taught him, patiently, with her hands in it and her voice low, as if loud talk might startle the flow.
They watched the spring together. That was the agreement made at the council fire, and it was a quieter agreement than any Elias had expected. There was no guard posted with a rifle and a grim face. There was no fence raised and no lock forged. Ren and Elias simply came to the spring at dusk and stayed into the dark, and Nash came and went on his scouting rounds, and the camp went about its evening business within earshot, which was itself a kind of watch. A thief who wanted the spring would have to walk past a whole people to get to it, and a people who had been warned were not easy to walk past.
Elias brought his soldier's patience to the work. He had learned patience in trenches and on picket lines, in the long hours when nothing happened and a man had to stay awake anyway, listening for the one sound that did not belong. He sat with his back to a cottonwood and his buckskin hobbled nearby, and he listened. The creek talked all night in its small voice. The wind moved through the grass in waves. Somewhere above them, an owl asked its question and received no answer. Ren sat beside him, not close enough to crowd him and not far enough to be apart, and she mended a torn shirt with stitches so small and even that Elias, watching her hands in the firelight, thought of the way his mother must once have mended, before the summer throat-ailment took her when he was four and left him with no memory of her hands at all.
On the third night, Nash came down from the ridge with his step quiet and his face thoughtful. He had found nothing that night, he said, but he had found something the night before, and he had waited to be sure before he spoke of it. There were boot prints near the spring that were not theirs, and not the camp's. They were the prints of a man who wore town boots, with a heel worn down on the outside, and they came from the direction of the trail that led back toward Lark Spur Flat. Nash had followed them a little way and then turned back, because following a man alone in the dark was a good way to get a man killed, and Nash was not in the habit of getting himself killed for a footprint.
Elias studied the prints the next morning with Ren beside him. They were there, plain as print in a book, pressed into the soft earth where the creek overflowed after the last rain. A town boot, yes. A heel worn on the outside, as Nash had said. And beside them, fainter, the print of a second man who had tried to step in the first man's tracks and had not quite managed it. Elias felt the old soldier's anger rise in him, cold and steady rather than hot, and he felt Ren's hand on his arm, not restraining him, but reminding him that anger was a tool and not a master.
We will watch closer, Ren said. "Not harder. Closer. A man who comes to steal water will come again, because he will want to be sure of what he saw. And when he comes, we will be here."
So they watched closer. Elias learned to sit without fidgeting, to let his eyes adjust until the dark became a country he could read. Ren learned to sit without speaking, which was harder for her, because silence had been her armour for five years and now she found she liked the sound of her own voice when it was not guarding anything. Nash came and went, and sometimes he sat with them a while, and sometimes he was gone for hours, and when he returned he always had something to report: a coyote at the far bank, a deer drinking at midnight, a wind that had shifted and would bring rain by morning.