I have thought on it, Elias said. "My answer is no. It was no before you rode in, and it will be no in a week, and it will be no next year. This ground is not mine to sell, and even if it were, I would not sell it to a man who begins by warning my wife."
Crowe's face did not change, but something went out of his eyes, as if a calculation had been closed. He untied his horse and mounted, slowly, and looked down at them from the saddle.
Then I wish you well, Whitlock, he said, in a tone that wished nothing of the kind. "Men who refuse good offers sometimes learn the price of refusal."
He rode away without looking back, and the dust settled behind him in a thin, pale trail. Elias and Ren stood at the fence until the sound of the horse faded, and then Ren let out a breath Elias had not realised she was holding.
He will not come back himself, she said. "He will send paper next. Paper is quieter than a man."
Let him, Elias said. "Paper can be checked. Wilkes has taught us that much."
That night they checked the spring twice. The first time was at dusk, when the light was still good enough to read the ground, and they walked the whole edge together, Ren pointing out the places where the water ran clearest and Elias marking, in his mind, the boot prints that were theirs and the ones that were not. There were none that were not theirs, and Ren nodded, satisfied, and touched the water with her fingertips as if to reassure it.
The second time was after dark, when the camp had quieted and the stars had come out in their thousands over the red peaks. They went without a lantern, because Ren knew the path by feel, and Elias followed her footsteps rather than his own eyes. The spring was a dark mirror under the sky, and the only sound was the water moving over stone and the night birds settling in the grass. Elias stood guard while Ren knelt and listened, her head bowed, not in prayer but in attention, the way a person listens to a thing they are responsible for.
It is sound, she said at last, rising. "No one has been here since we were."
They walked back together in the dark, and Elias thought that there were worse ways to end a day than walking home beside a woman who knew the ground under her feet better than any surveyor ever would, after refusing a man who thought everything had a price. He did not say so aloud. He did not need to. Ren's hand found his in the dark, briefly, and then let go, and that was enough.
Deputy Sam Wilkes did not make a show of an arrest. That was the first thing Elias noticed about the morning it happened, and it stayed with him afterwards as a kind of lesson in how law ought to look when it is working properly. There were no crowds summoned, no rifles raised for effect, no shouting in the street. Wilkes rode into Lark Spur Flat with two men he trusted, went to the boarding-house where Tanner had been lodging since the confrontation at Otis's store, and knocked on the door the way a man knocks when he expects it to be opened.
Tanner opened it himself, and Elias, who had ridden in with Ren and waited across the street by the hitching rack, saw the exact moment Tanner understood that this was not another argument. Arguments could be blustered through. This could not. Wilkes held a folded paper in his hand, and he read from it in a voice that carried just far enough for the men on the porch to hear, and no further.
Cyrus Tanner, Wilkes said, "you are arrested on the forged claim made in Elias Whitlock's name to the Lark Spur Land Company, and on the evidence of the raid upon the camp spring. You will come with me to the territorial office, where the paper will be examined, and where you will answer for it."
Tanner looked past Wilkes, across the street, and saw Elias standing there. For a moment his face worked with the old bitterness Elias had heard in the street before — the bitterness of a man who believed the world had given another man luck it had denied him. Then he looked at Ren, who stood beside Elias with her hands folded and her face calm, and something in him seemed to go flat, as if he had run out of speeches.
You were always the lucky one, Whitlock, he said, but there was no force in it now. It sounded like a line he had rehearsed too many times and no longer believed.
Elias did not answer. There was nothing to answer with that would make the morning better. He had served in the same regiment as this man. He had shared fires with him, and rations, and a road west. That was what made the forgery cut deeper than a stranger's theft would have. A stranger steals. A friend, pretending to be a friend, steals and then smiles while he does it. Elias had learned, since Ren, to check a story before believing it, and the story of Tanner's friendship had not survived checking.
Wilkes put the irons on Tanner without roughness and without ceremony, and led him to a waiting horse. Boone Riker was brought out a little later, from a different building, by one of Wilkes's men, and he went quietly too, his head down, as if he had already decided that silence was the best he could do for himself now.