Elias stood. He did not reach for a weapon, because he had not brought one to the spring, and because Ren had taught him that the spring was not defended with iron but with presence. He stood in the path between the men and the basin, with the water at his back, and he shouted back, not in anger, but in the clear, carrying voice of a man who has given orders on a battlefield and knows how to make himself heard across a field. "This is Iron Elk's water!" he called. "You have no paper that holds here, and you know it!"
Ren was beside him before he had finished speaking. She did not cower and she did not run for the camp, though the camp was already waking to the noise. She stood at the spring's edge, her hands spread wide, as if she could shield the basin with her body alone, and she called out in a voice that was steady enough to cut through Riker's bluster. "This spring feeds children!" she cried. "It feeds old people! It feeds horses and gardens! You will not take it with a barrel and a lie!"
The shouting grew. Riker shouted about the company. Elias shouted about the council. Marsh shouted something nobody could make out, and then he stopped shouting, because he had seen the camp coming. The camp did not come as an army. It came as a people waking to a noise at their water, men and women and older children pouring down from the lodges with buckets and blankets and whatever they had in their hands, shouting too, not in rage, but in a great, rolling wave of voices that said, in every tone at once, that this place was theirs and that strangers who came with ropes in the dawn would not be welcomed.
Water did the rest. Someone — Elias never learned who, and it did not matter — tipped a bucket at the edge of the basin, and the water splashed across the path, and Riker, stepping back from the splash, slipped on the wet stone and sat down hard in the mud, which took the dignity out of his shouting in a single, undignified moment. Marsh laughed, despite himself, and then clapped a hand over his mouth, as if laughter were a betrayal. Tanner, seeing his plan dissolve into shouting and mud and a whole camp awake and watching, turned to go, but Nash was there, coming down from the ridge at a run, and Nash was not alone. Two camp men were with him, and they were not carrying weapons either, but they were carrying the authority of men who had been sent by the council, and that was heavier than any rifle.
The raiders broke. Not in a rout, with shots and screams, but in the shabby, stumbling retreat of men whose plan has failed in front of witnesses. Riker tried to run and was caught, not by violence, but by Nash stepping in front of him and by the camp closing around him, quietly, firmly, until there was nowhere to run that did not pass through people who were not afraid of him. Marsh ran, and was let run, because a man who runs from his own raid has already confessed, and the council would deal with him in its own time. Tanner ran too, on foot at first and then, finding his horse where he had left it, on horseback, back down the trail toward Lark Spur Flat, with the dust of his going hanging in the morning light.
And then, in the quiet that followed the shouting, Ren found Red Hawk. He had not run. He had not shouted. He had stood at the edge of the spring all through the raid, with his face turned away, as if he could not bear to look at what he had allowed. When Ren took his arm, gently, he did not resist. When Elias looked at him, he looked at the ground. And when Nash, searching him as the council's man, opened the pouch at Red Hawk's belt, there was a coin in it — a single, bright coin, new-minted, that had no business in a camp man's pouch on a morning when raiders came for the spring. Red Hawk looked at the coin, and then at Ren, and then at the water, and his shoulders fell, and he said nothing at all, which was confession enough for everyone standing there.
Nash kept Riker seated on the wet stone while two camp men stood nearby, not threatening him, but making it plain that he would not walk away until the council had seen him. Riker stared at his muddy boots and said nothing. Ren knelt at the basin and examined the stones the raiders had kicked loose, lifting each one and setting it back with care. She checked the outlet, cleared a clump of silt with her flat stone, and watched the water find its course again, clear and steady. The camp people who had come running began, quietly, to go back to their work, carrying their buckets and blankets, speaking in low voices about what they had seen. Elias stayed at the spring's edge until the last of the raiders' footprints had been noted and the barrel they had brought stood empty and foolish beside the path, a reminder that men who come to steal water rarely understand water at all.