Tanner fled then, not with dignity, but with the hurried, stumbling flight of a man who has run out of words and knows it. He pushed through the crowd toward Crowe's office, and the crowd parted for him, not out of respect, but out of the sudden, collective understanding that a man who has been named in the open has nowhere left to hide in a town as small as Lark Spur Flat.
Tanner did not stay in Crowe's office long. He could not have stayed, even if Crowe had wanted him to, because Wilkes was already on the trail, and because a town that has heard a man's name spoken aloud in the street does not let that man sit quietly behind a closed door. Tanner rode out of Lark Spur Flat in the late afternoon, with the dust of the street still on his coat and the bitterness of his last words still in his mouth, and he rode hard for the place where he believed his protection lay: Wendell Crowe, of the Lark Spur Land Company, who had paid him, who had promised him, and who, Tanner believed, would stand behind a man who had done the company's dirty work.
Crowe was in his office, which was the largest room in the town, with a desk too big for it and a map on the wall that showed the canyon water in blue ink, as if ink could make water belong to a company. When Tanner burst in, Crowe looked up, and his face did not show surprise. It showed calculation, which was worse, because a man who is not surprised by a fugitive has already decided what to do with him. Crowe listened to Tanner's story — the raid failed, Riker caught, Red Hawk confessed, Mae testified, Wilkes holding the forged paper — and he listened without interrupting, which was not kindness, but the patience of a man counting his losses.
And then Crowe disowned him. He did it in public, which was the cruellest way to do it, because he did it in front of his clerk and his hired men and anyone else who happened to be in the office doorway, and he did it with the smooth, regretful voice of a man who has practised regret the way other men practise signatures. Tanner, he said, had acted alone. Tanner had misunderstood his instructions. Tanner had taken a good company's honest interest in the canyon and turned it into something shameful, and the company would not be held responsible for the actions of a man who had gone beyond his orders. He said it as if he believed it, and for a moment, Tanner believed that Crowe believed it, which was the saddest part of the whole affair.
Tanner's ride to Crowe had been a hard one, and he arrived with his horse lathered and his coat torn at the shoulder where a branch had caught him on the trail. He had rehearsed his plea all the way, telling himself that Crowe would listen, that Crowe owed him, that the company could not afford to lose a man who knew the canyon trails and the camp's routines as well as he did. He had told himself, too, that Elias had been lucky, that luck was the only difference between them, and that Crowe, who understood business, would understand that luck was not a crime. By the time he reached the office door, he almost believed his own rehearsal, which made what followed harder to bear, because a man who arrives believing he will be saved falls further than a man who arrives expecting nothing.
Tanner stood in the office, with his coat dusty and his hands shaking, and he understood, finally, what Elias had understood years ago on a Missouri porch: that a man who sells his name to a company does not own his name any more, and that a company will return a name the moment it becomes inconvenient to carry. He tried to argue. He tried to remind Crowe of the payments, of the ledger, of the promises made in this very room.
The clerk, who had stood in the doorway through it all, watched Tanner's pleading with a face that grew paler with every word, because the clerk had kept the company's second ledger, and he knew that every payment Tanner named was written down, and that every denial Crowe uttered was a lie the ledger would contradict. Later, when Wilkes came to him, the clerk did not need much persuading. He brought out the ledger from the drawer where Crowe had told him to keep it, and he laid it on the desk, and he said, simply, that he was tired of keeping books for men who disowned their own ink. Wilkes thanked him, and the clerk, relieved and frightened at once, sat down heavily, as if a weight he had carried for months had finally been set down. Crowe smiled, and the smile was the smile of a man who has already burned the evidence he does not need, and who believes that a burned ledger cannot speak.
But Wilkes was unimpressed, and Wilkes was thorough, and Wilkes had been following paper longer than Crowe had been writing it. The deputy did not arrest Crowe in his office, because the law, like the council, prefers a judgement that holds to a judgement that merely feels good. Instead, Wilkes followed the paper trail, as he had promised Elias he would, from the forged claim to the land office, from the land office to the company's filings, from the company's filings to a second ledger, kept not in Crowe's office, but in the land office itself, where a clerk, frightened by Mae's testimony and by the town's new willingness to speak, had kept a copy of every entry Crowe had made.