medicine will wait." And she had poured again, slow, and the spoon had come up level, and she had stirred it three times, and she had carried the cup to him, and he had drunk it, and he had said, "Thank you," and she had thought, I can do this. I can do this every night, for as long as he needs me to. And she had done it, every night since, and her hand did not shake anymore, and the spoon came up level every time, and the medicine did its work, and Ephraim's cough had eased, a little, and she was proud of that, in a quiet way, the way a woman is proud of a thing she does well and no one notices.
In the afternoon, when the washing was done and the bread was baked, Susannah sat by the window with her sewing, and she thought about Prudence. She had never met Prudence Nash. Prudence had died in the autumn of 1888, a year before Susannah had come to Owl Creek, and Susannah knew her only through the house, and through Ephraim, and through Wren, and through the small things Prudence had left behind: the blue teapot on the shelf, the quilt on the children's bed, the sampler on the wall that said, in faded thread, "Bless This House," and the white cup in the cupboard, the one Prudence had drunk her medicine from, which Susannah had never used, and never would use, because it was Prudence's cup, and it belonged to Prudence, even in death.
Susannah did not try to be Prudence. She had decided that on the first day, when she had come to live in the house, and she had seen Prudence's things, and she had felt the weight of them, and she had thought, I will not take her place. I will not sit in her chair. I will not use her cup. I will not ask the children to call me Mother. I will only be Susannah, and I will cook, and I will wash, and I will sew, and I will keep the house, and I will love them as best I can, and that will have to be enough. And it had been enough, for Ephraim, and for Eli, who was small enough to climb into her lap, and it had not been enough for Wren, and Susannah knew that, and she did not blame Wren for it, because Wren had been five when her mother died, and five-year-old girls do not give their hearts away easily, and they should not have to.
She thought about the two years since she had married Ephraim, and about all the small kindnesses she had tried, and about how Wren had received them: politely, and coldly, and from a distance, the way you receive a gift from a stranger. She had made Wren a dress, blue, with white buttons, and Wren had worn it, and she had said, "Thank you," and she had not smiled. She had read to Wren in the evenings, and Wren had listened, and she had not leaned against her, the way Eli leaned against her. She had braided Wren's hair every morning, and Wren had stood still for it, and she had not pulled away, and she had not leaned into it either. And Susannah had thought, many times, She is waiting for me to fail. She is waiting for me to do something wrong, so that she can be right not to trust me. And I will not fail. I will not give her a reason. I will be kind, and I will be steady, and I will be patient, and one day she will see that I am not her enemy.
But now Wren was watching the brown bottle, and Susannah was afraid, in a way she had not been afraid before, because this was not a small thing, like a dress or a story or a braid. This was her husband's life, and her stepdaughter's fear, and the two of them were tangled together in a way that frightened her, because if Wren truly believed that Susannah was doing Ephraim harm, then Wren might do something, and Susannah did not know what that something might be, and she did not want to find out.