He leaned back in his chair, and he closed his eyes, and he thought about the doctor. The doctor had come in the autumn, when the cough had got so bad that Ephraim could not sleep through the night, and the doctor had listened to his chest with his ear pressed against it, and he had shaken his head, and he had said, "Your lungs are full of dust, Ephraim. You must take this tonic every night, one spoonful in a tin cup of water, and you must not miss a night, and you must not take more than one spoonful, and you must not take less." And he had written it down on a piece of paper, in his careful hand, and he had given the paper to Ephraim, and Ephraim had put the paper in the drawer beside his bed, and he had kept it there ever since.
And Susannah measured it. That was the arrangement. Ephraim had asked her to, because his hands shook sometimes after a long day at the mill, and because a spoonful was a small thing to get wrong, and because Susannah had steady hands and a careful eye, and because she was his wife, and he trusted her. She measured it every night, one spoonful, no more and no less, and she stirred it three times, and she brought it to him, and he drank it, because he must, because without it the cough was worse, and the nights were worse, and the mornings were worse, and a man who could not breathe could not work, and a man who could not work could not keep a house.
But Wren did not know that. Wren saw the brown bottle, and she saw the dark drops, and she saw her father drink, and she thought what a child would think, and Ephraim knew that, and he knew he had to tell her, and he knew he had waited too long already, and he did not know how to begin, because how do you tell an eight-year-old girl that the bitter thing in the cup is keeping her father alive, when the last bitter thing in a cup did not keep her mother alive?
He thought about Prudence. He thought about her every day, even now, three years after she died, and he thought about her most at night, when the house was quiet and the cough had eased and his mind had nothing else to do. Prudence Nash had been his wife for ten years, and she had been Wren's mother and Eli's mother, and she had been the best person he had ever known, and the fever had taken her in the autumn of 1888, and it had taken her fast, and it had not cared that she was good, or that she was young, or that she had two small children who needed her.
The fever had come on a Tuesday. Prudence had woken with a headache, and by noon she was hot to the touch, and by evening she was shaking, and the doctor had come, and he had left a bottle, and she had drunk from a white cup every night, and the medicine had been dark and bitter, and she had drunk it all, every night, for three weeks, and it had not saved her. Ephraim had sat beside her bed, and he had held her hand, and he had said, "Drink it all, Prudence. The doctor says it will help." And she had drunk it all, and she had smiled at him, weak as a candle flame, and she had said, "I am trying, Ephraim. I am trying." And then one cold morning in November she had stopped trying, and she had stopped breathing, and she was gone, and the house had gone so quiet that Ephraim had thought the walls would crack from the silence.
He remembered Wren standing in the doorway that morning, five years old, with her hands at her sides, not knowing where to put them, and he remembered Eli, three years old, crying because he did not understand, and he remembered that he had not known what to say to them, and he remembered that he had picked Wren up and held her, and she had been stiff in his arms, like a board, and he had thought, She is afraid of me now. She is afraid because I could not save her mother, and she thinks I will not be able to save anyone.
After Prudence died, the house had been a hard place to live in. Ephraim had cooked badly and washed badly and sewn not at all, and Wren had tried to help, small as she was, and Eli had cried at night, and the neighbors had brought food, and the food had run out, and the winter had been long, and Ephraim had gone to the sawmill every day and come home every night and sat in his chair and stared at the fire, and he had thought, This is my life now. This is what is left.