She thought about the winter of 1888, when her mother had lain in the back bedroom coughing just like that, and how Wren had sat on the floor beside the bed with her doll, and how her mother had smiled at her between coughs, and how the bitter medicine had stood on the bedside table in a brown bottle, just like Papa's, and how her mother had drunk it, and how she had died anyway, and Wren thought, "Mama drank it and died, and Papa drinks it and he is getting worse, so the medicine cannot be what is keeping him alive, and I was right to take it away, and tomorrow I will tell him why, and he will understand, and he will thank me." She held on to that thought the way she held on to her quilt, with both hands, and at last, just before dawn, she slept.
In the morning the light came in gray through the window, and Wren got up with her eyes burning, and her head heavy, and she went downstairs, and the house was quiet, and Susannah was at the stove, and her face was pale, and Papa was sitting at the table, and he looked worse than he had looked the night before, and his face was gray, and his hands shook a little when he picked up his coffee cup, and he coughed into his handkerchief, and the cough sounded deep and wet, and Wren stood on the bottom step, and she looked at him, and she thought, "He looks sick. He looks sicker than yesterday. Did I do that? Did hiding the bottle do that?"
Susannah had searched the kitchen again before Wren came down. Wren could see it in the way the jars had been moved, and the way the cupboard door stood open, and the way Susannah kept looking at the shelf, as if the bottle might come back if she looked at it long enough. She had looked in the pantry, and she had looked in the bedroom, and she had looked on the porch, and the bottle was gone, and Wren knew where it was, and she said nothing, and she sat down at the table, and she ate her bread, and it tasted like nothing, and Eli chattered about his frog, and nobody told him to be quiet, and Papa tried to smile at him, and the smile did not reach his eyes, and Wren thought, "He is weak because he did not have his medicine. But the medicine is poison. So how can he be weak because he did not have poison? That does not make sense. Unless the medicine is not poison. Unless I was wrong."
But she could not have been wrong. She had seen it with her own eyes, three nights in a row. The dark drops, falling into the cup. The spoon, stirring. The cup, carried to Papa's hand. She had written it down. It was in her copybook, in her own hand, and her own hand did not lie. And yet Papa looked sicker this morning than he had looked in a long time, and he had not had the medicine, and if the medicine was poison, then not having it should have made him better, not worse, and Wren did not understand, and not understanding made her afraid in a new way, a way that was worse than the fear she had felt before, because before she had been afraid for Papa, and now she was afraid of herself, and of what she had done.
After breakfast, Papa stood up slowly, holding on to the back of his chair, and he said, "Wren, come and walk with me to the barn," and his voice was hoarse from coughing, and Wren's stomach went tight, and she followed him out the back door, and the morning air was cold, and the yard was white with frost, and they walked to the barn together, and Papa did not speak, and Wren did not speak, and the barn door stood open, and the hay pile stood in the back, and the bottle was inside it, deep inside it, and Wren thought, "He knows. He knows I took it. He is going to ask me, and I will have to tell him, and then everything will be different."
They stopped just inside the barn door, where the light fell in a long strip across the dirt floor, and Papa turned to her, and he looked down at her, and his face was tired, and his eyes were kind, and he said, "Wren. I want you to tell me the truth. Do you know where the bottle is?"