And then Susannah had come. It had been the spring of 1889, half a year after Prudence died, and Susannah had come to Owl Creek to visit her sister, and Ephraim had met her at church, and she had been kind, and she had been steady, and she had not tried to be Prudence, and she had not tried to take Prudence's place, and she had said to him, plain as day, "I know your wife is gone, Ephraim, and I know you loved her, and I do not ask you to forget her. I only ask you to let me help." And he had let her help. And then he had asked her to marry him, and she had said yes, and they had married in the summer of 1889, and she had come to live in the house, and she had cooked, and she had washed, and she had sewn, and she had kept the house, and she had been good to Wren and Eli, and she had never once raised her voice, and she had never once been cruel, and Ephraim had thanked God for her every night, in his own quiet way, because a man does not always say his thanks out loud.
But Wren had never trusted her. Ephraim knew that, too. He had seen it from the first day, the way Wren stood behind his leg and looked at Susannah, and the way she did not smile back, and the way she called her Susannah and not Mother, and the way she watched her, always watched her, the way a child watches a stranger who has come into her house. He had hoped it would pass. He had hoped that two years would be enough. But it had not passed, and now Wren was watching the brown bottle, and she was watching Susannah's hands, and she was watching her father drink, and Ephraim knew, in the way a father knows, that his daughter thought her stepmother was doing him harm, and that thought sat in his chest heavier than the cough.
He got up from his chair, slow, because his chest hurt, and he went to the window, and he looked out at the dark, and he thought about what to do. He could tell Wren now, tonight, and show her the doctor's paper, and explain it all, and she would understand, or she would not, because she was eight years old, and eight-year-old girls do not always understand what their fathers tell them, even when their fathers tell the truth. Or he could wait, and choose the right evening, when the house was quiet and the children were calm, and sit her down, and tell her slow, and show her the paper, and let her hold the bottle, and let her smell the medicine, and let her see that it was the same medicine the doctor had given him, and not something Susannah had made up in the dark.
He decided to wait. Not long. A day or two. Until the right evening. Until he could find the words. Because the words mattered, and he did not want to get them wrong, and he did not want to frighten her, and he did not want her to think he was angry with her for watching, because watching was not a bad thing. Watching meant she cared. Watching meant she was trying to keep him safe, the way he had tried to keep her mother safe, and failed. And he would not punish her for that. He would not punish her for loving him.
He went upstairs then, slow, holding the rail, because the stairs were steep and his chest was tired, and he stood for a moment outside Wren's door, and he listened, and he heard her breathing, slow and even, asleep, or pretending to be asleep, and he thought about going in, and sitting on the edge of her bed, and telling her then and there, and he did not, because it was late, and because she was tired, and because the right evening was not this evening, with the lamp low and the house half asleep, but another evening, when they could sit together in the light, and he could show her the paper, and she could see it with her own eyes.