Do Whatever You Want,” the Cowboy Said — But the Apache Woman’s Next Words Changed Everything

Chapter 30

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Bennett met her at the door, and his eyes were troubled, and he said, "Naya, I have to hold you overnight. Malloy has made a formal claim, and I have to check it. I cannot simply turn him away without looking, or the next claim will be worse, and the next sheriff will be less careful than I am."

She understood, and she did not forgive Malloy for it, but she understood Bennett's position, and she said, "Then hold me, Sheriff. But write down that I deny it, in my own words, and that I ask for Calder and for Dr. Cole to be sent for. A night in a cell will not make a lie true."

Bennett did write it down, in his round, deliberate hand, and he gave her the cell at the back, which was clean and dry, and he brought her water and a blanket, and he locked the door, and he sat at his desk for a long time after, looking at the paper Malloy had left, and at the report he had written about the fence and the spur, and at the two things together, and he knew, with the sinking feeling of a man who had been used, that he had been made into Greer's instrument for a night.

Word reached Circle V before dark, carried by the boy with Betsy, who rode hard and told Calder in a rush: Naya held, horse theft, Malloy's claim, Bennett's office. Calder listened without interrupting, and his face went white around the mouth, and then he moved, fast and sure, gathering Seth, and Eli, who insisted on coming despite his ribs, and Dr. Miriam Cole, who had been tending Calder's arm and who understood, at once, what a night in a cell could do to a woman who had once been tied to a post.

Dr. Cole wrote, by lamplight, a statement in Naya's own words, dictated by Naya herself in the weeks before — no, Calder corrected himself, that would not do. He needed Naya's own signed statement, and he needed it now, and he could not get it from a woman locked in a cell. So he did the next best thing, and the only honest thing: he took the spur, both spurs, and Bennett's own report, and he took Seth, who could speak for his sister's character and for the bay gelding that had never existed in Greer's remuda, and he took Dr. Cole, who could speak for the rope marks and the healing and the woman she had come to know, and he rode through the night for Copper Bend, because a night was too long to leave a free woman in a cell on a lie.

They rode in the dark, through country that was cold and empty, with Calder's bandaged arm aching and Eli breathing shallowly beside him, and Seth riding point, and Dr. Cole riding steady in the middle, and none of them spoke much, because there was nothing to say that would make the horses go faster. The stars were bright and hard overhead, and the moon gave just enough light to see the road, and Calder thought about the post, and about the rope, and about the first words Naya had ever said to him — do whatever you want, cowboy, you are all the same, finish it — and about how far they had come from that morning, and how fragile that distance still was, when a single paper, waved in a street, could put her back behind bars.

On the road, Dr. Cole rode beside Calder for a time, and she told him, quietly, what she had seen in Naya in the weeks since the post: a woman who healed others before she healed herself, who remembered every plant and every patient, who had sat up with Eli when his fever rose and who had never once asked for thanks, only for the freedom to do her work. She said that a sheriff who held such a woman on a paper claim would learn, in time, that paper could be wrong, and that the town would learn it too, if Calder stood at the jailhouse door and said so plainly, without shouting and without a gun in his hand. Seth, riding ahead, turned back once and told Calder that the bay gelding Malloy described did not exist in Greer's remuda, because Seth had seen that remuda, and he knew its horses, and he would swear to it before Bennett or before any judge, and that a lie about a horse was a small lie, but small lies were how big thefts began. Calder listened to them both, and he felt his anger settle into something harder and cleaner: not the anger of a man who wanted revenge, but the anger of a man who wanted a record set straight, and a woman set free, and a town to see, at last, who was stealing and who was being stolen from. He thought about the spur in his saddlebag, and the second spur beside it, and the report Bennett had written in his own hand, and he knew that he was not riding to Copper Bend to beg. He was riding to present a case, and to stand at a door, and to wait, if he had to wait all day, for that door to open.

News in the same category

Do Whatever You Want,” the Cowboy Said — But the Apache Woman’s Next Words Changed Everything

45 Part