Do Whatever You Want,” the Cowboy Said — But the Apache Woman’s Next Words Changed Everything

Chapter 39

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

From the east, dust rose. It was thin at first, a smudge against the lightening sky, and then it thickened, and then the sound came with it, the low, rolling sound of many horses moving at a walk, not a charge, not a stampede, but a deliberate advance. Harlan Greer rode at the front of it, fifty-eight, his shoulders squared inside a coat that was too fine for the country and too familiar to the men who worked for him, his face set in the hard, practised lines of a man accustomed to having his claims taken seriously because he said them loudly enough. Behind him rode a dozen men, and among them, riding a little too close to Greer and a little too far from the rest, was Deke Malloy, forty, foreman, his jaw tight, his eyes narrowed against the light. Malloy had been charged already, in Copper Bend, with assault and arson and a false report, and the fact that he rode free that morning, at Greer's shoulder, was itself a kind of statement, and Sheriff Bennett saw it and his mouth thinned to a line.

The two groups stopped thirty yards apart, with the cedar post standing between them like a witness that could not be bribed or frightened. For a long moment no one spoke. The horses stamped and blew. A fly settled on Betsy's neck and she twitched it away. The wind moved through the mesquite and carried the smell of dust and horse sweat and the faint, iron smell of the clay after a night without rain. Calder felt his own heartbeat, steady and slow, and he felt the weight of the Winchester in its scabbard, and he felt, more clearly than either, the weight of Naya beside him, waiting, not for him to speak for her, but for the moment when speaking would be hers.

Greer broke the silence first, because men like Greer always broke the silence first, believing that the first voice owned the ground. "Vann," he said, his voice carrying across the hardpan, flat and hard. "You have been told to keep to your side of this fence. My cattle need that spring country, and my claim is filed in Copper Bend. You have no right to turn my riders away, and you have no right to harbour a woman who was lawfully bound."

Calder did not raise his voice. He had learned, in the war and after it, that a raised voice was often a confession that a man had run out of true things to say, and he had true things to say that morning, and he intended to say them where every man present could hear them and remember them later, when Greer was not standing there to glare at them. He swung down from Betsy, slowly, and stood with his boots planted in the clay, his hat in his hand for a moment, and then back on his head, and he looked first at Greer, and then at Malloy, and then at the post, and then back at Greer, and the order of those looks was deliberate, and everyone there understood it.

Harlan, Calder said, and his voice was quiet, and quiet carried better than shouting in that thin morning air. "I am not here to fight you with a gun. If you want a gunfight, you will have to start it yourself, and Sheriff Bennett is standing right here to see who does. I am here to ask you, before witnesses, to answer for what happened on this ground. For a woman lashed to a cedar post with hemp rope until her wrists bled. For a fence cut and a line cabin burned. For a false report filed in Copper Bend that said she was a thief and a runaway, when she was neither. Answer for the post, Mr. Greer. Answer for the rope. Answer for the fence and the fire. Not with a claim on a spring. With the truth."

A murmur ran through Greer's riders, not loud, not agreement, but the sound men make when a question lands where they did not expect it to land. One rider shifted in his saddle. Another looked down at his hands. Malloy's face darkened, and his hand moved, almost without his deciding it, toward his belt, and then stopped, because Bennett's deputies had shifted their weight, and because Bennett himself had taken one step forward, his hand resting, easy and unmistakable, on his own hip. Greer laughed, a short, harsh sound that did not convince anyone, least of all himself.

You think a speech makes you a lawman, Vann? Greer said. "You think because you cut a rope you own the valley? That woman was taken for a debt her people owed. Malloy was doing my business, and my business is lawful. Your fence is in the way of water my cattle have used for years, and I will have that water, with papers or without them."

Naya's horse moved, a single step forward, and Calder felt rather than saw her straighten beside him. He did not turn to stop her. He had promised himself, on the night he cut her down, that he would never again decide for her what she could bear, and he kept that promise now, even with his heart hammering against his ribs, even with Greer's riders watching her with the wary attention men give to a person they have wronged and cannot quite bring themselves to name. The post stood behind her in the morning light, and the valley lay open all around them, and the dawn, which had been pale and thin, began at last to warm, to colour the clay and the mesquite and the faces of the men who had come to that boundary to see which way the country would go.

Naya did not raise her voice either. She did not need to. When she spoke, the valley seemed to lean in, not because she commanded it, but because she had earned, in pain and in patience, the right to be heard on that ground, and because every man there, even Greer's riders, knew that the woman tied to the post had not begged and had not broken, and that the woman standing before them now was the same woman, only unbound. She rode forward until her horse stood beside Calder's, until she was close enough to the post that its shadow fell across the clay at her feet, and she looked at Greer without flinching, and at Malloy without hatred, and that, Calder thought, was harder than hatred, and braver.

News in the same category

Do Whatever You Want,” the Cowboy Said — But the Apache Woman’s Next Words Changed Everything

45 Part